Does anyone even use pencil eyeliner anymore?!

Mar 19, 2014

Jocelyn S.

Just curious. I haven't tried liquid or gel...I just use pencil and keep it basic...does anyone else just use pencil? I need like a liquid liner that is dummy proof and that goes well with blonde lashes if I venture over to that spectrum.../rambling.

Mar 19, 2014

Maressa H.

I still use pencil! I use liquid liner sometimes, but mostly just pencil :)

Mar 19, 2014

Haley G.

I use the rimmel scandaleyes pencil liners sometimes, and the nyx wonder pencil on my water line, but other than that, no. Liquid all the way! You should try a felt tip pen liner, jordana fabuliner at walgreens is my HG liner (lasts longer on me than lancome art liner, my old HG), and is only 1.99. its like holding a marker, and the non flexible tip makes it very easy to control :)

Mar 19, 2014

Monique R.

I use the MAC kohl eyeliner in Smoulder! I don't think I will ever stop using it. I have the MAC fluidline in black track but I've yet to master the winged liner. & I refuse to wear it unless it's perfectISH. And even when I do get it down I will for sure still use my pencil for the bottom. :)

Mar 19, 2014

M G.

I don't. feel like the odd one out lol.

Mar 19, 2014

M G.

They look great Hannah.

Mar 19, 2014

Hannah M.

Really thank you I have no idea what I'm doing haha :( but have no shape before I fill them in.

Mar 19, 2014

Hannah M.

And nope gel and liquid eyeliner all the way for me haven't used pencil since grade 9 haha.

Mar 19, 2014

M G.

Well your doing a good job :)

Mar 19, 2014

Helen M.

Yes

Mar 19, 2014

Jocelyn S.

@hannah is red your natural hair color?

Mar 19, 2014

Roz X.

I love Stila liner. Rich pigment and long wearing. I use pencil in my waterline only.

Mar 19, 2014

Yaya B.

I love maybelline eye studio gel liner..I'm not a pro amd find it very easy to apply..for my water line I either use it aswell or use the retractable pencil...from maybelline aswell.

Mar 19, 2014

Kristina C.

I use it in the water line I rele like Marc Jacobs gel eyeliner pencil.

Mar 19, 2014

Brittani J.

I love love love the Estée Lauder eyeliner pencils. I'm not a fan of gel and liquid eyeliners, I'm a pencil girl :)

Mar 19, 2014

Shelley W.

I love pencils! Retractable, old school pencil...love em in my waterline to make top lashes look full especially if I using gel liner for a winged look.

Mar 19, 2014

Amy M.

If I had to choose just one type of eyeliner it would definitely be a felt tipped liquid, but a pencil is absolutely necessary in my opinion to have. I mean, have you ever tried lining your waterline with a liquid? I always get black all over my eyeballs! Thank goodness I wear contact lenses and my eyes are extremely UNsensitive or it would be hell. That's where pencil is indispensable!!

Mar 19, 2014

Hannah M.

Hey Jocelyn no it's not it's actually quite faded there but I use garnier olia in intense red it's a beautiful colour x

Mar 19, 2014

Chantelle louise L.

Only use a pencil to dip in a gel liner and apply to my waterline haha! Then on top of lids would so recommend the felt tip liners, I am so clumsy and un-proffessional when it comes to makeup and the felt tip liners are so easy and hassle free to use!

Mar 19, 2014

Gypsy S.

I guess it depends what look I'm going for. Like my profile pic I used a pencil and just smudged it like crazy...but if I want I want a nice clean look I turn to gel or a felt tip liquid💋💕

Mar 19, 2014

Danielle B.

I feel like everyone's favorite tends to be the one they learned with! I love the subtle look that you can get with pencil but since I started with a liquid on a small brush- I'm best with liquid or gel on a brush. I feel like I have 5 yr old finger sometimes trying to work with a pencil. Soooo not smooth. hah

Mar 19, 2014

Roz X.

I use pencil for smudging or on my waterline. :)

Mar 19, 2014

Sevetria M.

mainly pencil