REVIEW: Rimmel ScandalEyes Waterproof Eyeliner.

9

Sort By

Mar 9, 2014

Honey B.

This is one of the WORST eyeliners. I'm so disappointed in Rimmel because their products are usually great and affordable. This eyeliner is not it! Don't buy it, save your money! It can only be used to wing the outer part but that's it. It's not even waterproof as well! It's also not pigmented, you have to keep lining it. Their ScandalEyes eyeliner pot is better and is actually waterproof.

Mar 9, 2014

Danny C.

Good to.know thanks. I just tried this it was also a big fail. the loreal liner w the brush tip was 1000x better

Mar 9, 2014

Emilie W.

^^ I agree with ya!

Mar 9, 2014

Honey B.

@Danny C. Oh okay. I haven't tried LOreal liners...I have the maybelline one which lasts a really long time. I just recently got the revlon eyeliner. Lol I just can't find the "perfect" eyeliner!!

Mar 9, 2014

Honey B.

@emilie w. What do you use?

Mar 9, 2014

Heather I.

Good to know..I usually like rimmel. I ha went tries that one though. I've tried Avon e.l.f., Revlon maybelline.

Mar 9, 2014

Danny C.

The best I've tried was the loreal w the brush applicator. it stays on dosent smug or crack amd is matte not shiny. still looking for a felt tip that will work equally as well

Mar 9, 2014

Renee K.

I've had really good luck with NYX liquid liners and physicians formula has a great one too.

Mar 9, 2014

Kayli H.

I recently picked the new Milani Eye Tech Extreme liner and it is phenomenal!!

Mar 9, 2014

Naomi S.

Honey b, so sad.
I also posted about the scandal eyes liquid eyeshadow being a letdown. *sigh. what the hell is goin on rimmel!??  ;-)

Mar 9, 2014

Honey B.

@Naomi S. Lol I also don't know!! Their ScandalEyes in the pot is nice tho but this one was such a let down, I mean honesty! I was so happy to try it out and it failed!! Hopefully they get it together!!

Mar 9, 2014

Honey B.

@Kayli h. Yesss! That eye tech is awesome and it stays on eventho it's not waterproof! Recently, it started smudging on top of my eyes so I stopped using it but for a while, I used nothin but the eye tech so maybe I need to get a new one cuz so far it's the best eyeliner I've tried!

Mar 9, 2014

Honey B.

@Renee K. I got the nyx fat eyeliner marker and I was not impressed at all!

Mar 9, 2014

Honey B.

@Danny C. Are you talking about the infallible? That comes in a pot with the brush?

Mar 9, 2014

Honey B.

@danny c. Are you talkin about the one in the pot with the brush? The infallible?

Mar 9, 2014

Elizabeth D.

I use Almay's liquid eyeliner in Black Pearl for Hazel Eyes. it works really well for a simple tightline or a sophisticated cat eye.

Mar 9, 2014

Elizabeth D.

My twin uses Pati Dubroff automatic waterproof eye pencils. The colours are amazing!

Mar 9, 2014

Renee K.

I haven't used the fat marker, it was one of the others. My go to is maybelline's gel liner though. I seem to have better luck than with liquid liners by far!

Mar 9, 2014

Meagan B.

My holy grail liquor liner is Lorac Front of the line pro...super dark and pigmented, doesn't budge and the applicator is AWESOME! It's a little pricey though, but I think it's well worth it since it works so well

Mar 9, 2014

Naomi S.

I've heard good things about the lorac one.

Mar 9, 2014

Emily W.

I really like my NYX Skinny Marker, super easy to use, pigmented, and lasts for days!

I haven't tried this one, but I have a couple of the Rimmel ScandalEyes waterproof kohl pencils and they are awesome. :)

Mar 9, 2014

Danny C.

this one Honey

Mar 9, 2014

Naomi S.

Oooh. that looks fun.. maybe I'll try that since it worked for you Danny. I do like a little shine vs matte but if its pigmented enough the matte would b smokn hot!

Mar 10, 2014

Danny C.

Naomi its fab ul love. just be sure to full in between your lashes w a pencil or something. they did offer a patent black as well at one time but I didn't care for it I liked the matte way more

Mar 11, 2014

Naomi S.

I'm going to grab one at some point soon. thanks Danny.