E.L.F. or Wet n Wild?

Oct 1, 2011

Maggz M.

I'm curious.
Personally I think E.L.F. is gentler on my skin, but I prefer Wet n Wild's verity. :D

Oct 1, 2011

Lola M.

Depends on the products. I wont use any of their liqid face products. I love Wet n Wilds eyeshadows and blush. On the other hand I dont like any ELF except maybe their brushes, but I dodn have a bad experience with those.

Oct 2, 2011

Yasmin K.

Wet 'n' Wild. ELF is too much of a miss for me.

Oct 2, 2011

gee m.

I actually love both lines. I love, love, love wet n wild eyeshadows, I try and find every eyeshadow they come out with. I would also like to try their lipsticks and their blushes I just haven't because I want to use up some of the lips products I already have. I also like a lot of products from E.L.F Usually I place a order with E.L.F. online because when I go into Target the selection isn't that great. When I do order online I usually wait for their sale and purchase the products I like and also purchase some of the products I am interested in trying. . 

Oct 2, 2011

Maggz M.

I agree, trying to find ELF, is hard, and WnW is much easier. :)

Oct 2, 2011

Angie K.

Hard one! I really like some Wet n Wild shadows, amazing pigmentation, but some I find quite powdery and hard to blend. We can't get WnW over here in the UK anyway (the ones I have were sent to me by friends). I have a ton of Elf products and although it can be hit and miss, the majority is a hit for me, and so inexpensive.

Oct 2, 2011

Jalaina S.

ELF is great especially for the price. If a shadow or something doesn't work out for you its not like your out more than a $1 or so. I haven't used much WnW. I think I remember using it as a kid. So it may be that I'm realating it to cheap kids makeup.

Oct 2, 2011

Dana N.

ELF is pretty great. I love their eyebrow kit and their face primer! THe only thing about their line that I don't like is their brushes. I feel like they don't pick up the color or powder as great as other brushes and I honestly couldn't say anything about Wet n Wild because I honestly haven't tried any of their products even though their stand is right next to the ELF stand at my Target.

Oct 2, 2011

Rai C.

I like both brands! 

Oct 2, 2011

Ashley K.

I'm partial to ELF only because I have had bad experiences with wet and wild. Some of their products break me out and I don't have that problem with the ELF line.

Oct 3, 2011

Stephanie F.

Too hard to choose, definitely. Both hit or miss, both great for certain things. ELF for matte powder, lip gloss, and even some brushes. Wet N Wild for eyeshadows and glitters.

.--Cookie

Oct 3, 2011

Kristen I.

I like both for different things.

Oct 3, 2011

Christina K.

I love wet&wild, just bc its cheaper, i never tried elf..but my walgreens has elf paletts, that im deff going to buy on friday :)

Oct 3, 2011

Jaelin E.

Wet 'n Wild, I've found every E.L.F. product that I've ever tried to not work well and Wet 'n Wild to be surprisingly useful for it's low price. 

Oct 3, 2011

Arie C.

Wet 'n Wild. Love their products. ELF is very hit or miss.

Oct 3, 2011

Mary S.

I love both brands. However I feel like Wet n' Wild is more consistent. And I've been using it much longer 

Oct 3, 2011

Stephanie F.

I forgot, I love wet n wild nail polishes!

--cookie

Oct 3, 2011

Atiyah Y.

I love them both. 

Oct 4, 2011

Natasha E.

I like the simplicity of the E.L.F. packaging and the variety of WnW....I like them both!

Oct 6, 2011

Cinthia V.

I feel that both are great. I prefer Wet N Wild eyeshadows. Way more pigmented and smooth. Elf's are a bit chalky in my opinion. On the other hand, I love Elf lipsticks. 

Oct 8, 2011

Shelley W.

I've bad experiences with Wet'N'Wild but discovered ELF and I especially love the brushes. Haven't drifted over to the cosmetics yet I know I will make it there sooner rather than later.

Oct 9, 2011

Samantha G.

ive found a lot of things that i love from elf. i do like wet n wild's eyeshadows and blushes but i dont feel like they carry a lot of product

Oct 10, 2011

Anneka F.

I'm totally obsessed with ELF. But I haven't tried much of Wet n Wild. Where can I get it?
It looks like I should probably try their eyeshadows huh? haha. 

Oct 10, 2011

Ashley G.

ELF <3 

Oct 10, 2011

Jalaina S.

ELF has awesome customer service. Check out this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxisF8z_8P4