Good eye makeup removers?

54

Sort By

Jul 3, 2012

Haley W.

I am SICK AND TIRED of tugging and rubbing roughly over my eyes to get all my makeup off. I'm left with eyelashes falling out and irritated, puffy eyes. Where can I find a holy grail eye makeup remover?

Bifesta waterproof eye makeup remover. not sure if they have it outside of asia though

Jul 3, 2012

Mary P.

Lotion! hands down, the best to remove eye makeup....

Jul 3, 2012

Olivia G.

Paw paw ointment is really gentle and won't irritate your eyes at all!

Jul 3, 2012

Candi D.

Makeup forever sensitive eyes eye makeup remover. Removes eye makeup in one swipe. 

Mix water and extra virgin olive oil together shake before you apply on a. Makeup pad it works really good

Release Me by Philosophy is what I use. It's really good. 

Jul 3, 2012

Izzy T.

Garnier makeup wipes and lotion

Jul 4, 2012

LaToya C.

I agree with Mary P. lotion has worked miracles for me when I first started using makeup ad when I run out of makeup remover. :) but I do use the Sonia kashuk one from Target. I love it and it's the only one that doesn't or hasn't burned my eyes. :) 

Jul 4, 2012

LaToya C.

*and

Jul 4, 2012

Jovita W.

I'm 39 yrs old and I have not one wrinkle. My mom always taught me to use olive oil to remove all make up and eye make up with it. Get about a buckle size in ur hands rub together then rub all over face including eyes wipe off with a warm wash cloth then go behind it with ur face wash it'll leave ur face soft as a baby's butt and all make up and eye make gone! It's cheaper then buying all those eye make up removers 

Jul 4, 2012

Jovita W.

*nickel

Jul 4, 2012

Soraya P.

MAC's Cleanse Off Oil, this way you don't have to use a cotton wipe and tug, you can easily pump once in your hands and rub over the eye in one direction. Make sure your eyes are closed tight and you have a sink in from of you to rinse off immediately. When you add water to the oil, it immediately converts it into a solution that easily washes off, therefore no oily residue left. Than you can follow with your normal skin regime.

Jul 4, 2012

Rachel K.

i found pond's face cream to work pretty well. the equate brand by walmart makes the makeup remover that i use most, which you have to shake because it has two different consistencies, one of which is oil-like but it is oil free. almay makes a mineral oil one that is great at removing makeup, by far the best. clinique makes a super expensive and only slightly better one than that i buy from walmart. i think i may switch to the almay one.
i would NEVER use olive oil. i know some people are posting that and although it make work for some, it gets a 2 out of 5 for being comedoogenic, so if you ever have clogged pores, this will probably clog you somewhat frequently. mineral oil gets a rating of 0, meaning it just won't clog them. the only oils that will not ever clog pores are: shea butter, hemp, petrolatum, safflower, and sunflower oil. 

http://www.beneficialbotanicals.com/facts-figures/comedogenic-rating.html

I agree with Rachel K on the Pond cream. Lush has one called Ultrabland which I LOVEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE.

http://www.lushusa.com/Ultrabland/02749,en_US,pd.html

Jul 4, 2012

Alice T.

Extra virgin olive oil is amaazing! Doesn't clog pores and it will remove anything! x

Jul 4, 2012

Nakia P.

Ole henriksen wipes are great plus their good for ur skin n peep this u only need 1 for the entire face!

Jul 4, 2012

gabbyy H.

Seporhra make up remover but baby oil works SO much better just a couple rubs and everything gone and it makes your skin soft 

Jul 4, 2012

Sara C.

My No.1 make up remover especially for my eyes BIODERMA it's so hard to get in UK but it's amazing, not a big fan of the green one even though it's aimed at my type of skin. RED BIODERMA ALL THE WAY! x

Mary Kay Oil-Free Makeup Remover, Best stuff in the world hands down!

Jul 4, 2012

Tina W.

I really live the loreal eye make up remover :) I've been using it for years and it hasn't failed me yet :)

Also. A lot of my friends use vaseline and the make up just slides right off :) 

Jul 5, 2012

Nadia N.

Bifacil by Lancôme is great and Bioderma is great too

Jul 5, 2012

Lauren S.

I've been using Rimmel London's eye makeup remover for years and I absolutely love it!

Neutrogena makeup remover towelettes are my favs and they leave your skin moisturized and soft. 

i use neutrogena makeup remover towelettes. i buy them from costco wholesale and they come in a huge box for really cheap. besides them being cheap, they are so good at taking makeup off without the excess oil. getting any type of oil on my skin makes my skin breakout so much. so i recommend these if you have oily skin or breakout easily. also, the fact that the makeup remover is a wipe and not liquid, makes them very useful in cleaning up your entire face full of makeup. liquid makeup removers to me get wasted so easily because so much of it soaks up into the pad, the pad gets covered easily in makeup so you have to keep getting a new pad and putting makeup remover on it, and it accidently spills. so i recommend trying out netutrogena makeup remover wipes so much!! (: