They're Real vs. Smokey Lash

6

Sort By

Jan 4, 2013

Kaysey L.

These two mascaras are pretty much the same price. I was wondering which you would choose out of the two.

Jan 4, 2013

Angela M.

They're real mascara! 

Jan 4, 2013

Iris L.

They're real is better for looks but it's bad for your lashes!

Jan 4, 2013

Iris L.

Not to mention extremely hard to take off. 

Jan 4, 2013

Pixie T.

Both are great mascaras... Though i lean more towards MakeUp Forever's Smoky Lash. It had a nice dark pigment and gives me tons more volume. I would describe it as a full, fluttery feathery lash type effect. Heavenly! 

Jan 4, 2013

Pixie T.

I should also mention that I usually don't use it as an everyday mascara. I find the smoky lash is better for nights out, dates, photos.. Anytime you desire a more dramatic lash 

Jan 4, 2013

Shay R.

So smokey lash is darker pigmented and gives more volume then they're real. They're Real is going to be more length then volume because of the brush on it. They're real as much I do like it. It dries out very fast. just an fyi

Jan 4, 2013

Megan M.

They're real! But I haven't tried the other.. Benefit did a good job though =]