Neutral palette for...

11

Sort By

Aug 14, 2014

Hannah K.

...people who don't like neutrals?

I've been contemplating neutral palettes for a while now, but I can't find one that holds my attention. I hated the Naked palette, I gave it to my friend, the Naked basics got returned, and the Amrezy palette was so disappointing that I returned it after only a weekend.

I tend to like more orange/red toned eyeshadows, in terms of neutrals, but I haven't been able to find any that really call to me. I'm really hoping that y'all will have some good suggestions for me to check out and maybe get :) thanks!

Aug 14, 2014

Yeji K.

My top 5 eyeshadow palettes:
-too faced chocolate
-kat von d monarch
-clinique all about shadow 8 pan palette
-lorac pro palette
-lorac pro to go

Aug 14, 2014

Hannah K.

I have the Monarch, and I love it, but honestly the others really don't stand out, the colors are very dull to me. Like I said, I like orangey-red shadows, if I'm going for neutrals :) thank you so much for your opinion, though.

Aug 14, 2014

Hannah K.

The one that's kind of a dupe for the Naked 3, Em?

Aug 14, 2014

Hannah K.

Well, I hope Em likes it then :)

Aug 14, 2014

Rissa G.

Lorac pro?

Aug 14, 2014

shayna h.

Stila actually had one called natural for $20 at ulta. I actually like it. obviously not. many choices as the larger palettes but it had a highlighter as well as a bronze!

Aug 14, 2014

Alexis M.

Have you tried smash box full exposure?

Aug 14, 2014

Alexis M.

~

Aug 14, 2014

Alexis M.

Oh you said you didn't like neutrals. Oops I didn't read that part

Aug 14, 2014

Delaney K.

Have you checked out the new stila eyes are the window palettes? the matte one (I think it's the mind palette) is neutral but not like your classic neutral palettes. I bought the body pallete and was super impressed with it.

Aug 14, 2014

Kaitlin R.

Too faced chocolate bar palette for sure.

Aug 14, 2014

Lorna G.

Hey Hannah,
I don't know if you've tried the Chocolate bar palette. But, I have to say there is definitely some subtle organge/red hues comming through their neutrals. It's funny enough, I don't like the chocolate bar, as my as my other neutral palettes, due to that reddish tinge, all the dark shadows seem to have, particularly cherry cordial.

Black forest truffle: red/maroon hue throughout the shadow
Amaretto: maroon hue throughout the eyeshadow
Cherry cordial: Definately a red hue comming through the shadow
Those three eyeshadows for me personally, where the worst when it came to that red hue. I say worst, because I don't really like using red hue eyeshadows for myself personally. :)

I hope this helped. :)

Aug 14, 2014

Hannah K.

Oh my, thanks y'all :) I know I'm picky, I just find that most neutral palettes are actually, frankly, boring. It's part of why I was so disappointed with the Amrezy palette, I thought that it was for sure going to have the perfect red-Georgia-clay eyeshadow, and then the shadow itself was awful. But that's the kind of color I'm talking about, like Morocco or Caramel from the Amrezy palette. Thank you all for your suggestions, truly, I do appreciate it :)

Aug 14, 2014

Hannah K.

Oh, and Delaney, where can I get that Stila palette from? That bottom middle shade is speaking to me :)

Aug 14, 2014

Breeze T.

Love that Stila palette!! <3.

Aug 14, 2014

Delaney K.

ulta and sephora!