Looking for a long lasting black matte eyeliner.

6

Sort By

Aug 31, 2014

Dini M.

Hey guys!
So it has been a while since I've started this hunt and I have still yet to find the perfect product. I'm looking for a waterproof/long-lasting MATTE black eyeliner because I tend to have crying eyes (I always kind of cry whenever I laugh so my winged eyeliner gets ruined). I'd like the eyeliner to be a liquid eyeliner with a BRUSH tip (no felt tip or anything).
To Sum It up : Waterproof matte black liquid eyeliner with a brushtip.
(I hate shiny/glossy finishes in eyeliner and I do have a gel eyeliner with MAC's blacktrack but I only use it whenever I have a party or something but for an everyday use I like using liquid eyeliener because it's easier and quicker)
Thank you!

Aug 31, 2014

Carsam R.

Try Kat Von De lock it tattoo eyeliner.

Aug 31, 2014

Lisa S.

Definitely Kat Von D's! It last me from 7am-11pm (or longer!). Similar to Stila's but Stila's is too shiny, KVD looks amazing and I use it everyday and I've had it since Feb. and its still got a lot of product left...

Aug 31, 2014

Alli P.

Well there's no such thing as the "lock-it tattoo eyeliner", but I agree with both Carsam and Lisa. Any of Kat Von D's eyeliners will do the trick. I'm completely obsessed with her Ink liner.

Sep 2, 2014

Shauna S.

I also love the Kat Von D Tattoo Liner. I use the one with the brush tip. It's intense black and the tip isn't too long so it won't dry out fast. I find in the corners of my eyes it can sometimes smudge. My friend said sometimes it smudges for her when she does a wing, but I've never had this problem and I have very watery eyes and oily eyelids. Stila has the best staying power in my opinion but it's very shiny and I find it bleeds slightly into the skin.

Sep 2, 2014

Dini M.

Thank you all! Living in France we don't have any Kate Von D or even Stila but if it's really worth it and won't smudge all over and ruin my wing at the end of the day then I'll definitely order it. But I've never been really a fan of pen like eyeliner bc I'm scared it might dry up quickly but Kate Von D products looks like it will be worth it. Is her Autograph eyeliner the same? Is it a brush tip or felt tip? (I can't tell over the pictures)

Sep 2, 2014

Lisa S.

I use either of these, not for sure what the difference is but I've had great luck with them. I highly recommend getting it. I have had one of mine since Feb. and it is still not even close to drying up, so its definitely worth it. I've seen some problems with this on reviews but I've had three of them and they are great. The Autograph is just a pencil I believe, so no, its not the same as the liquid.

Sep 2, 2014

Lisa S.

💕

Sep 2, 2014

Lisa S.

Oh I jus looked at the description and the Ink Liner is a felt tip and the other is more of a brush. I prefer felt tips, because I feel like it is easier to get more of a precise line and is just generally easier to apply.

Sep 2, 2014

Lisa S.

Stila's is great but it is not matte, so I recommend KVD's. Its still a great liner though, but I didn't like Stila's for everyday because of that shiny, wet look.

Sep 7, 2014

Dini M.

Lisa : Thank you for your answers! I'll try to get my hands on it when I'll order something in the US. I bought a KIKO waterproof eyeliner, the waterproof formula is amazing, that thing doesn't smudge, budge or anything even after 12 hours, supports crying and so on.. BUT.. the product and formula in itself is terrible : the liquid is thick as hell and the application is hard because the brush goes all over the place.