Best eyeliners for waterline.

19

Sort By

Jul 5, 2014

Rebecca J.

What are the best eyeliners for the waterline? I've tried mac smoulder and it smudges like crazy and I've tried a clinique one, rimmel and bourjois but same problem..

Jul 5, 2014

Shelley W.

I like Make Up For Ever and Urban Decay for my waterline.

Jul 5, 2014

Rebecca J.

I've tried the rimmel gel on my waterline but it stings :( ill try urban decay as mufe is hard to get where I live

Jul 5, 2014

Mariam A.

Too face waterproof eyeliner pencil

Jul 5, 2014

Elizabeth S.

Kohl eyeliner is the best

Jul 5, 2014

Bree B.

MUFE Aqua Eyes.

Jul 5, 2014

Hannah K.

Okay so let me tell you a story about Urban Decay. I used Zero on my waterline this morning at 9:30. It's now 2:30 and I've just finished an hour long core fusion hot yoga class. I'm now walking 15 minutes back to my house in 85 degree Atlanta weather. Here's what my eyeliner currently looks like.

Moral of the story: Urban Decay is the bomb, and it works like a charm for me.

Jul 5, 2014

Jessie D.

I use maybelline gel liner. This thread is seriously tempting me to buy urban decay liner now though.

Jul 5, 2014

Gypsy S.

I use the maybelline gel also but after seeing Hannah's post I'm so going to try Urban Decay😉💋

Jul 5, 2014

Hannah K.

Hope it works out for you ladies!

Jul 5, 2014

Gypsy S.

Thank ya babes! I'm excited to try it!!☺️

Jul 5, 2014

Rebecca J.

I'm tempted to get ud now :) thanks!!

Jul 5, 2014

Hannah K.

No problem! Let me know if you like it :)

Jul 5, 2014

Mia Z.

I use one from maybelline, it's waterproof so it stays put. I think it's called unstoppable

Jul 5, 2014

Hannah K.

Really, Lindsay? I used Perversion for a really long time and I never had that problem at all.

Jul 5, 2014

Jocelyn S.

I use urban decay and it's really soft and doesn't hurt during application. I find the Smashbox pencil liner separates and ends up everywhere in my eyes. UD all the way! (Haha, it's rhymes).

Jul 5, 2014

Alyx T.

Lindsay that's strange, I used perversion for months. It was like the only liner that didn't cloud up my contacts haha.

Jul 5, 2014

Hannah K.

Exactly, Alyx. Though I've been lucky, the only eyeliner I've ever had cloud my contacts was an original, vibrant blue Nars Eyeliner Stylo (which is a felt tipped marker), and I accidentally got it into my eye and my contacts turned blue so everything was blue tinted, and I didn't realize for a full day what was happening!

Jul 5, 2014

Alyx T.

Haha Hannah I've definitely had that happen with liquid liners. Usually black, but I used red once and well that was an interesting few minutes haha.
Pencil usually does cloud up my contacts, but the UD ones don't. I don't really wear any lately because I ran out of the UD one and haven't had the chance to buy another, but the ones I've been trying cloud my contacts or are just irritating/non lasting.

Jul 5, 2014

Hannah K.

That's so surprising. I've worn contacts for 11 years, and basically nothing I've tried (except that one damned eyeliner) has clouded them. I'd be happy to recommend some brands and stuff if you want to branch out from UD liners.

Jul 5, 2014

Rebecca J.

What's the difference between perversion and zero by the way? is one just blacker than the other I presume? and I hope it won't cloud my contacts either cos I do get the problem with some eyeliners! :(

Jul 5, 2014

Kitty K.

@Rebecca When I tested them out in store, perversion seemed a lot darker than zero.

@Hannah
9th grade... someone gifted me a liquid liner... I thought I could use it on my inner waterline - so I tried it out in the middle of class! LMAO oh my god that was so bad lol.

Jul 5, 2014

Nilam P.

Mac PowerPoint waterproof pencil

Jul 6, 2014

MaKenzie T.

I agree with Hannah. UD rocks. I use Black Market by them on my waterline, stay for hours and hours. And it doesn't gather in yur tear ducts like some products do.

Jul 6, 2014

Genevieve D.

Is the UD perversion hard to remove? I always have a hard time removing liner on my water line :\