Best Smudge Proof Eyeliner

Sort By

Jan 12, 2011

Tianna N.

Trying to find a smudge proof and waterproof pencil eyeliner. I hate putting eyeliner on then having it smear on my lower lashline or on the inner corners of my eyes. Any recommendations? Thanks!

Jan 12, 2011

Emma W.

urban decay 24/7 glide on and from the drug store Revlon colar stay 

Jan 13, 2011

Renee M.

I agree with Emma. Urban Decay's are amazing. Also MAC has Fluidline which is a waterproof eyeliner too. LOVE that stuff

Urban Decay 24/7 and also makeup forevers aqua eyes are great! Smashbox's limitless are pretty good as well. And for drugstore I like the revlon colorstay!

Jan 16, 2011

Romee H.

I had no luck with pencil eyeliner stay all day. So I changed to gel liner, Physicians Formula Gel liner(comes with 3 different colors) love them! Goes on so smoothly and stay on all day!! Plus you can't go wrong with 3 different color ^^

Feb 22, 2011

Kristen Z.

Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes was created for an underwater ballet team. Smudgeproof, fadeproof, waterproof, everything proof!

Feb 22, 2011

Tara R.

I agree with Kristen, MUFE Aqua Eyes do not budge for anything! the only thing is they can be a little dry at first, you need to warm them up a bit before you apply.

Urban Decay and Make Up Forever are really good ones. I really love my Stila one though! The only one to date that I can wear all day at the office without the need to reapply on my waterline and it doesn't smear underneath to give me that ever so lovely raccoon look!

Mar 17, 2011

Soma S.

I agree with MUFE Aqua Eyes... it's so budgeproof, it's almost a pain to get off, but their Sense-Eyes eye makeup remover is the answer to all waterproof makeup removal! Gel liners are fantastic though, and my MAC blacktrack fluidline does the trick for me. Also, set your liner w/ eyeshadow to seal it in for even more superior lasting power.  =D

Mar 19, 2011

Airi M.

Urban Decay 24/7, no question. It'll run you $17, but it would take three drugstore liners to do it's job.

Mar 19, 2011

Shelly T.

Don't know about waterproof, but it's definitely smudgeproof: Prestige Total Intensity eyeliner. IMO, it's much better (and more pigmented) than UD 24/7 and 1/3 the price!

Mar 20, 2011

Haley B.

Urban Decay 24/7 are good. My all time favorite is the mac fluidline, once it sets its there for awhile and it stays on the waterline forever
!! If you are going for pencil get 24/7, if you want the best get fluidine :) 

Mar 23, 2011

Desiree D.

I dont know if its just me but I've tried urban decay 24/7 as well as MUFE aqua eyes eyeliner. But at the end of the day they either disappear or they just smudge over 

Mar 23, 2011

Shelly T.

Desiree, it's not just you. I'm not a massive fan of UD's 24/7 liners. Like I said, Prestige = much more pigmented, has better staying power, and 1/3 the price.

Mar 24, 2011

Sydney R.

MAC's powerpoint eye pencil in Engraved and MUFE Aqua Eyes liner are both great!

Mar 28, 2011

Kris E.

MUFE's Aqua Eye Liner -- but beware, it's tough as nails to get off (practically anything they have with "aqua" is hard to get off lol), but if you're looking for a better bang for your buck, I highly suggest Milani's Liquify Liner

DEFINITELY MUFE's Aqua Eyes liners...

Check out my post on this product here:

Mar 31, 2011

Tina V.

Milani LIQUIF EYE Metallic Eyeliner Pencil from Target. works great everything else sumdges on me. even though it says metallic the black is a matte. make sure you let it set though its really soft sometimes i just take a angled liner brush and pick up some product directly from the pencil and apply it to my upper lashline or waterline. stays put ALL DAY.

Mar 31, 2011

Jane A.

It could be because I am oily, but the MUFE Aqua Eyes does rub off and smear on me. When I use a colorful one, or even the black on my eyelid, it rubs off by the end of the day. And when I use the black on my lower eyelid, it's gone by the end of the day. =|

I pretty much just use any liquid eyeliner on the top, and Loreal eyeliner on the bottom. The Loreal eyeliner stays put for well over 12 hours. 

Mar 31, 2011

Amanda K.

mufe is a great one and UD as well, but i find UD isnt as smudge proof as everyone claims it to be, its long lasting, but i find it will smudge eventually.. not very quickly but its still not as long wearing as it would have u think.. it also isnt waterproof... MAC fluidline is really great with not smudging for me..

Mar 31, 2011

Amanda K.

oh and i like bad gal waterproof as well!

UD *definitely* smudges. It glides on great, but it's overly creamy...and for everyday, it's too glittery for my taste.

Apr 04, 2011

Steph M.

for me, the MAC Technakohl eyeliners dont seem to smudge. it fades a little bit on the waterline, but otherwise ive had no other problems with it!

Apr 04, 2011

Diana G.

I agree that MUFE Aqua Eyes is good, but for me, my HG Smudge Proof Eyeliner = Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Eyeliner. It's a twist type liner that comes with a sharpener, and I've found that the color payoff is much better than MUFE. It's really rich, deep, color that dries quick so it's perfect for waterlines + lower lashline.

Jan 16, 2013

Tatiana M.


Add a Reply