Free shipping on all orders over $35 in the U.S.!

Blackest Matte Eyeshadow

Sort By

Oct 28, 2011

Jennifer-Rose J.

Waht company has the blackest matte eyeshadow? I'm looking for one that doesn't go green, but a carbon black. Any suggestions...

Oct 28, 2011

Soma S.

Sugarpill's Bulletproof eyeshadow puts MAC's Carbon to SHAME!

I never used Sugarpill's Bulletproof, but I have heard the most amazing things about it! I'd try that! 

Oct 28, 2011

Allison G.

Yeah I really don't think Carbon is all it's cracked up to be. I've found that NYX's plain black is WAY blacker.

Oct 28, 2011

Ida H.

Bulletproof by Sugarpill! No doubt! :D

Oct 28, 2011

Jane A.

I agree Sugarpill!

If you can't wait for the shipment (although they are quick), Wet n Wild has a "Blue had me at hello?" Or something like that... there is a black matte in that palette that is also blacker than carbon! 

I am going to have to try sugarpill now...OMG my husband is going to kill me lol

Oct 28, 2011

Zoe C.

Urban Decay's Peversion, Super super black! However, though I don't own any Sugarpill, I've heard they're very pigmented so give it a try! :)

Oct 28, 2011

Jennifer-Rose J.

I think I"ll definitely try the Sugarpill! They're pigments look fabulous!! That wet n nwild shade might be a quick fix though. I live right next to a Duane REade and I"m in there EVERY day. I'll pick it up today! Thanks guys!!

Oct 29, 2011

Shelly T.

MUFE #4 is another option if you want to spend a little more.

I would definitely say MACs "Dark Soul" pigment is awesome it's used in my profile pic.

Mar 12, 2012

Melissa A.

Loreal Lush Raven is ok. I hear Kat Von D has a good black

There are a lot of black Eyeshadows out there that are highly pigmented. A few that I own are: NYX's Black, Sleek MakeUP's Black that comes in all of their palettes and MakeupGeek's Corrupt :)

Mar 12, 2012

Kayli H.

There's a few in some of the Wet n Wild color icon pallets that are really nice, I would give them a shot since they're so cheap

Courtney A.

Mar 12, 2012

Courtney A.

I've heard that sugarpill is amazing, I haven't tried it though. My Inglot matte black is awesome, and I do also love MUFE

Mar 12, 2012

Yumi R.

I really like Carbon by MAC, especially overtop Blacktrack fluidline as a base! 

Looking for this myself...was going to get carbon, but now think I will reconsider!

Mar 12, 2012

Nicole C.

Makeup Geek - Corrupt.

They're only $5.99 and have the high end quality without the price. @ 1:52

I've gotta agree on the Sugarpill front. Bulletproof is AMAZING. Also Inglot have a pretty damn good matte black L(

Mar 12, 2012

Charnell C.

The top three blackest blacks:

1. MakeupGeek Corrupt
2. Nicka K high definition eyeshadow in #3037
3. Wet-n-wild matte black found in a variety of palettes.

Mar 12, 2012

Jacki C.

I've never tried Sugarpill but now I feel that I must try it!
BLACK OUT in the Urban Decay NAKED 2 is amazing! so pigmented.

Mar 14, 2012

Melissa A.

Urban Decay - Black Dog ..Make-up Geek eyeshadow pan - Corrupt.. Kat Von D - Lucifer.. still finding more. Good finds from all your previous finds. I'm buying Make-up geek Corrupt now. great price.

Sugarpill's Bulletproof. Hands down. All day.  Awesomesauce.

NYX Black is my favourite. UD Perversion. Wet'n'Wild blacks in various palettes, and single in Panther. I've never tried Bulletproof, but I've seen it used and recommend it by that alone.

Apr 11, 2012

Stacy N.

I heard so much about Sugarpill. I guess it is time to splurge!

Add a Reply