Best BLACK gel liner?

36

Sort By

Sep 3, 2012

Stacia J.

i need a crazy black gel liner that WONT move and i can put in my water line... no matter what liner i use on the bottom it always runs even when i set it :-( and the corners smear =((( help.. ive used all the drug store ones i could find so im willing to spend a little bit more but still not crazy spendy

Sep 3, 2012

Bec L.

The Essence gel liner is amazing. If you want to spend a bit more on a higher end one I've heard the Bobbi Brown one is good and I really like the Kryolan one.

Sep 3, 2012

Juliet S.

Bobbi Brown and also Maybelline. Shu Uemura is good also. Tom Ford is good but not long lasting as first ones

Sep 3, 2012

Brittany S.

I haven't tried a bunch of gels but I own sephora's and it doesn't budge!

Sep 3, 2012

Jordyn A.

Inglot AMC gel works great for all of that.

Sep 3, 2012

Ebony T.

Makeup forever aqua line in a pot

Sep 4, 2012

Kat L.

The tarte liner in a pot is pretty good for the waterline. I like it better than the MUFE pot because I find the MUFE pot dries out really fast- at least for me. 

Sep 4, 2012

Carla P.

I hear everyone likes the Mac fluid line but I love my tarte Amazonian liners in black and brown and the brush it comes with is the best!!! 

Sep 4, 2012

Sadie S.

L'oreal Maybeline an mac black track

Sep 4, 2012

Charlotte F.

MAC fluid line hands down

Sep 4, 2012

Alina B.

I love ESSENCE gel liner <3 !!!

Sep 4, 2012

Yesenia P.

Mac black track fluid or Maybelline

Sep 4, 2012

Michelle D.

I find that my Essence black gel liner works great. It's under $5 at Ulta. You can't beat that price for a good waterproof working gel liner.

Sep 4, 2012

Lera J.

I like YSL, Bobbi Brown, and Tarte...Black Cherry by YSL is my favorite....they all stay great. NARS new Larger than Life liners have a gel like texture even though they are in pencil form they are my favorite for the water line

Sep 4, 2012

Ginna D.

I recently bought the MICAbella gel liner and it is so black also it literally doesn't come off with water you have to take it off with eye makeup remover. It doesn't budge and dries fast. 

Sep 6, 2012

Tania A.

Mac fluid line or the sephora cream liner :)

Sep 6, 2012

Diana M.

How about e.l.f studio cream eye liner.. It's Smudge-proof, budge-proof and water-resistant and cost $3 at target or their website eyeslipsface.com 

Sep 6, 2012

Diana M.

www.eyeslipsface.com

Sep 7, 2012

Emily B.

Inglot AMC with duraline 

Sep 7, 2012

Tia B.

Tarte

Sep 7, 2012

Sidory D.

Diana, really? Got to try that. I use many different ones from MUFE, Revlon etc.

Sep 8, 2012

Billie R.

I agree.. I workout twice a day & Mac fluid line stays put..

Sep 10, 2012

Melanie E.

Makeup Forever Aqua Black

Sep 10, 2012

Melissa F.

Inglot in 77 and Mac gel liner in black track because Inglot has more staying power while Mac looks more glossy.

Sep 10, 2012

Nadia N.

Bobbi Brown or Fluidline