Trying to find the perfect eyeliner.

Jun 13, 2016

Elizabeth I.

Hello all. Does anyone know of a very good smooth, smudge-free eyeliner pencil to recommend? I've tried so many different brands and types, and I havent found one yet thats super smooth and smudge-free. Thank you!

Jun 13, 2016

Hannah P.

I found the Barry am ones to be quite good. they have a regular formula, where the pencils are the same colour as the nib, & waterproof ones where the pencil is black and the end is the same colour as the nib. I found they stayed really well, & they have some amazing colours
I also love the sleek eau la la pencils. they can be used on both the lips & eyes, so some colours are a bit weird on the eyes! they are quite long lasting, & stay vivid, & I didn't find they smudged much :)

Jun 13, 2016

Hannah P.

Also, I didn't find that either brand pulled when you were putting them on. they glide so easily, & both have great colour pay off.

Jun 13, 2016

Rebecca J.

Rimmel Scandaleyes works well for me. Or I've recently been using the makeup forever aqua eyes which is also brilliant.

Jun 13, 2016

Tina K.

MUFE Aqua Eyes, UD 24/7 and Mally's Everlasting liners are some of my favorites.

Jun 13, 2016

Elizabeth I.

Thank you all! I will look into all of these.

Jun 14, 2016

Camilla M.

I'm not that much into pencil liners, but I really love the Marc Jacobs one. That does not smise at all.

Jun 14, 2016

Camilla M.

Smudge

Jun 14, 2016

Elizabeth I.

Thanks so much! I will look at that one too.

Jun 14, 2016

Hannah K.

What have you tried thus far?

Jun 14, 2016

Elizabeth I.

I havent tried any of the suggested ones yet. So far I've only used Maybelliene, L'Oreal, Sephora, Bad Gal Benefit, and Revlon brands. Usually I use liquid eyeliner, but I'd like to try something a little more subtle.

Jun 14, 2016

Emma S.

I use some brown ultra shades, they work for me!

Jun 15, 2016

Elizabeth I.

Thanks!