Maybelline Define A Brow or Elf Brow Kit?

9

Sort By

Jan 16, 2013

Cameron R.

I have Elf's Brow Kit currently, and since I am hitting pan on the cream I am looking at repurchasing it, or trying Maybelline's Define a Brow because I have heard a lot of good things about it. I wanted to know if any of you who may have tried both would pick one over the other, and why! = )

Jan 16, 2013

Cameron R.

Oh, and please don't recommend any Anastasia products, I know there are a lot of enthusiasts on here, but I have tried a few different products by them and I feel like they don't perform any better (though worse, in some instances)than other less expensive alternatives.

Jan 16, 2013

Cameron R.

Thanks! I really like the ELF Brow Kit, but I keep hearing so many good things about the define a brow and it makes me want to try it!

I didn't see this post before I posted mine. Maybe I'll try the define a brow also. 

Jan 16, 2013

Katrina W.

Are you filling in brows or drawing them on/dramatically filling them in?

Jan 16, 2013

Cameron R.

Hey Melissa, I really really like the Elf Eyebrow Kit, it's probably the best I have tried so far if you haven't had a chance to try it. I just wanted to know basically if anyone thinks the Define A Brow is better than the ELF kit considering I hear so much about it haha

Jan 16, 2013

Victoria T.

I feel like theyre 2 different products. If you have gaps in your eyebrows that you really need to fill id go with define a brow. But if you just need to overall fill or darken your brows id stay with elf

Jan 17, 2013

Shai M.

I agree the Victoria T. I have both of these products and really like both. One thing I've heard and noticed is that Define-A-Brow is being phased out and replaced by a new product called Master Shape. This new product IMO is not nearly as good as Define-A-Brow. I have been buying as many as I can WHEN I can find it. 

Jan 18, 2013

Nicole A.

Stick with elf 

Jan 18, 2013

Alyssa K.

I love my elf brow kit (: it is the best product I have found for my eyebrows (:

Jan 18, 2013

Cameron R.

Thanks everyone! Yea I love it too! I just know a lot of people personally that love the Maybelline Pencil, and was just wondering if the effect was better in one or another.

Jan 18, 2013

Olivia H.

I honestly hated define a brow, the shades aren't true to their colors. I use the revlon double ended pencil that also has gel on it, and I love it.