Birch Box or Ipsy??

Jun 18, 2015

Laura V.

I'm thinking about signing up for one of these monthly. Have any of you don't that? Is it worth it?

Jun 18, 2015

Laura V.

Oh and if you have done both. Which on is better?

Jun 18, 2015

Laura D.

I love ipsy they give you four to five awesome items every month along with a makeup bag it is pretty awesome to open up your mailbox and find the products.😃

Jun 18, 2015

Julie F.

I've done both. I prefer birchbox. More quality products in my opinion. And had a better point system. Ipsy was nice too! They just send me stuff I didn't want (blue eyeliner..sparkly lip gloss)

Jun 18, 2015

Shanae J.

I'd have to say ipsy as well. Just because birchbox gives mainly skincare from what I've seen on YouTube, I like choosing my own skincare products myself and ipsy gives mostly makeup and I love trying new makeup products. It just depends on the person.

Jun 18, 2015

Shanae J.

I say watch a ton of YouTube videos and make your decision that way.

Jun 18, 2015

Jenny B.

I had both both before and honestly I love my ispy bag.

Jun 18, 2015

Amber K.

Check into boxycharm. I've had ipsy and birchbox and I like boxy much better. look up past boxes to c what it's like.

Jun 18, 2015

Shanae J.

Only thing is boxycharm is $21. ^

Jun 18, 2015

Julie F.

Shanae is right! Birchbox is a lot more skincare, hair care, lotions, shampoo/conditioner etc. although you do receive some makeup samples!! I did like ipsy! I just think the point system for birchbox wins me over. Check out the blog "my subscription addiction" she reviews them all

Jun 18, 2015

Shanae J.

I really do want to get birchbox though lol. I'm just broke.

Jun 18, 2015

Maressa H.

I've had ipsy for about a year now and I love it! I recently decided to give birch box a try as well and was completely unimpressed by it. I cancelled my subscription to birch box after only two boxes

Jun 18, 2015

Lola A.

Try ipsy! Birchbox had too many hair products or skin care products and ipsy has more makeup and usually comes with like 1 skincare product or hair product each time.

Jun 18, 2015

Lola A.

Also the amounts of the product were larger with ipsy

Jun 18, 2015

Melody W.

It depends on what you like! Birchbox has more skincare based items and ipsy is more makeup! That's what I've noticed atleast I love love love ipsy!

Jun 18, 2015

Emm J.

Ipsy x

Jun 18, 2015

Laura V.

Wow, thank you guys! Lots of help. :-)

Jun 18, 2015

Naomi K.

I have both..ipsy way better

Jun 19, 2015

Angela J.

I've had both and kept the Ipsy bc I like it much better:)

Jun 20, 2015

Emily B.

I've done both. I would say ipsy, and that's the one I kept for longer, but I cancelled because it kind of sucks...I got like two face or hand creams every time and barely any makeup. I have a whole load of stuff I'll never use, like face wash and hand cream. When they give out eye shadows they're always a boring beige color. My lipstick came broken once and they sent me a "replacement" that was not the same product-they gave me a star looks lipgloss instead! I already had like three of those-from their previous bags! It kinda sucked