Liquid or pencil eyeliner?

16

Sort By

Jan 4, 2014

Emilie W.

Which do you prefer? Pencil or liquid?

Jan 4, 2014

Christina C.

Pencil for bottom, liquid for top.

Jan 4, 2014

Nadra J.

Gel! But from your options, pencil.

Jan 4, 2014

Katherine R.

Pencil as a guideline then I trace it with liquid :)

Jan 4, 2014

Bekah S.

Pencil for lash lines, liquid for upper, gel above all :)

Jan 4, 2014

Monica O.

Pencil you have more control with

Jan 4, 2014

Paula E.

Used to think liquid but when I think about it, pencil works better on me.

Jan 4, 2014

Breeanna M.

Gel lasts the longest and is the best if both worlds, but I choose pencil over liquid because you have more control

Jan 4, 2014

Sarah L.

Unless you don't want to wing it out, I personally like liquid better- its smoother and provides for a good cat eye😊 + pencil you have to sharpen it all the time and I'd rather not have to do that tbh.

Jan 4, 2014

Jade S.

Liquid on the top, pencil on the bottom.

Jan 4, 2014

Teresa P.

Same... @christina

Jan 4, 2014

Beck H.

Pencil for bottom liquid for the top.

Jan 4, 2014

Amela S.

gel eyeliner!!

Jan 5, 2014

Maria M.

Liquid, then gel, then pencil.