NYX slide on pencils vs UD 24/7

5

Sort By

Sep 5, 2011

Katie P.

so I tried NYX's regular eye pencils but I'm having a hard time keeping them on my lids even with my primers! its so disappointing :/! I love the bright colors so I'm looking to re-buy something waterproof this time. I saw Urban Decay had their 24/7 waterproof liners (so pretty) but close to $18. then I saw NYX had their slide on pencils. they look similar and they're cheaper! I don't want to have to re-buy again so Ill spend the money on the better product! does NYX slide on pencils match up to Urban Decays 24/7 pencils? Ive heard mixed reviews...

Sep 5, 2011

Megan B.

i saw a yt video on them and they look pretty nice. i have yet to buy any yet...but i really want to try them!

personally, i would recommend the 24/7 pencils. I have quite a few and they hold up well against the NYX pencils (although I swear by the Jumbo eyeshadow pencils by NYX) ....however, i LOVE the smashbox eyeliners...but its all personal preference...maybe you could wait until ULTA has a NYX sale (which they should have going on right now) and you could get buy 1 get 1 1/2 so u could give the new NYX pencils a try....also, if u dont like a product at ulta or sephora they give u 30 days to return as long as u have a receipt and you havent used more than half of the product....hope that helps u some :)

also u can purchase NYX and UD at ulta :)

Sep 5, 2011

Katie P.

the NYX slide on pencils do look nice!
and Jessica your probably right maybe I just need to try them out before I go and buy 5 of something haha! I think they do have a NYX sale at ulta. I may just run over there and try one of each, NYX and UD. I have a feeling though youll get what you pay for. thanks for the great info I had no idea you could return if you didn't like a product - good to know! thank you much :] ! 

I just reviewed them on my blog!
http://www.lipgloss-flipflops.com/2011/09/nyx-slide-on-pencil-eyeliner-review.html you can check out the link if your interested!
I would HIGHLY recommend the NYX slide on pencils. I think they are just as good as UD but way more affordable!

Sep 6, 2011

Katie P.

oh wow that was really helpful! thanks too for the great info on your blog :D I will def have to try one out. Esmeralda is so pretty! I think I may have to get that one first! Ive been doing some research and so far Ive heard some pretty good things about these! maybe they will save me a bit of money :}  

katie, u are welcome! i returned one of my butter london polishes today cause the payoff sucked :) glad i could help ! xo

Sep 6, 2011

Rai C.

Love the NYX Slide On, but I HATE the UD 24/7! 

Esmeralda is a very pretty color!! I love wearing it with a light purple shadow, it goes so well together. My only downfall with these is they seem impossible to find unless you order off the NYX website.

Sep 7, 2011

Katie P.

this is good to hear!!

ohhh and green and purple sound gorgeous! I will have to try the combo out :] and Im not sure if you already know but beautyjoint.com has the NYX slide on pencils discounted. thats where I go to get NYX if I like something! its def somewhat cheaper. also Ive had good luck with porkdaisy.com. and Ive heard of cherryculture.com as well. maybe that will help! hope so :D

Awesome Thanks so much!!!

Im going to have to try these..Thanks