What's The Best Black Eyeliner Pencil??

16

Sort By

Apr 17, 2013

Basma F.

I usually use dark brown eyeliner pencil because black always smudge on me and It turns out looking like a zombie lol, but I really want to try using black because it's dramatic and makes you're eyes pop more! do you have any suggestions on what's a great waterproof black eyeliner pencil? and I don't like eyeliners I like pencils more...

Apr 17, 2013

Karina M.

I didn't like pencil because I wear contacts and I heard about mac pencil eyeliner and I love it specially in my water line it doesn't come off!!

Apr 17, 2013

Katie R.

Clinique has an amazing black pencil. The intense black is my FAVE! 
http://www.clinique.com/product/1597/12313/Makeup/Eyeliners/Quickliner-For-Eyes-Intense/index.tmpl

Apr 17, 2013

Mk rashmi M.

Even I wear contacts! so I prefer maybeline colossal
it its smudge free for 6 to 8 hours

Apr 17, 2013

Lena D.

The makeup forever aqua liners. Once it sets.. Does not budge until you use makeup removers. Ultra soft and creamy. But beautiful pigment payoff. And their blacks are intense. Same as urban decay 24/7 liners in zero! Same thing. Waterproof and fool proof! Holy grail eyeliners for me.

Apr 17, 2013

Basma F.

Aww thank you all so much I will definitely check them out :) that was so helpful.

Apr 17, 2013

Sevana M.

Mac feline is awesome for the water line!! It's my most have!

Apr 17, 2013

Amanda W.

It seems I can't get enough black eyeliner. the darker the better! Sephora or Kat Von D is what I use.

Apr 17, 2013

Brittany J.

Urban Decay 24/7 eyeliner in perversion!

Apr 17, 2013

Amanda W.

24/7 eye liner is amazing does not smudge or anything. I tend to apply it over black eye liner to give a dramatic smudge free look. great under eyeshadow too.

Apr 17, 2013

Shabrandis P.

MACs black eyeliner in Smolder is my absolute favorite! It's so easy to apply bcuz it goes on really smoothe and its as black as can be so it pops and doesn't look faded!!

Apr 17, 2013

Sarah D.

physicians formula

Apr 17, 2013

Jamie B.

Urban decay 24/7 glide on pencil is AMAZING!! I use it in a lot of my tutorials on youtube if you want to see how it applies :) www.youtube.com/jamiepaigebeauty.

Apr 17, 2013

Stefani S.

Mac PowerPoint! Love love this pencil!

Apr 18, 2013

Tiffany D.

The best I've tried is the UD 24/7pencil in zero.

Apr 18, 2013

Serena X.

For water line Mac Feline. and for outer eye I'd recommend Revlon color stay it is amazing!

Apr 19, 2013

Ty R.

Smolder by mac!