Black Eyeliner

27

Sort By

What is the best black eyeliner in your opinion? Both liquid and/or pencil.

Mar 22, 2012

Ida H.

Precision ink from Illamasqua in Abyss is the best liquid one in my opinion! For pencil I really like the Stila smudgestick in Stingray :)

Mar 23, 2012

keri k.

i like mac fluidline

Mar 23, 2012

Elizabeth G.

For pencil Urban Decay 24/7 glide on pencil in Perversion is the SICKEST black, hands down. For liquid liner, 24/7 Liquid in Perversion is also the best. :)

For a liquid, pen style liner, my favorite is Physician's Formula Lash Boosting Eyeliner in Ultra Black! I use it daily!

Mar 23, 2012

Alicia L.

I like Neutrogena's Nourshing Eyeliner, its really smooth and extremely black. For high end eyeliners, however, i would suggest the Urban Decay 24/7 glide on. 

Mar 23, 2012

Nichole W.

Pencil is Urban Decay 24/7 (Persuasion, I believe) and my favorite liquid (which I like way better then pencils) is L'Oreal Linuer Intense, second is Urban Decay 24/4 Waterproof Liquid eyes :) 

Mar 23, 2012

Queenie L.

bobbi brown long wear and milani liquif eye :)

OMG!!!
Pencil: Wet n Wild orrr Master drama
Liquid:NYC 

Mar 24, 2012

Chastidy R.

Lancome's black kohl(pencil) and their ARTLINER in black (liquid) im also a huge fan of LO'REALS TELESCOPIC WATERPROOF EYELINER

I really need to try Perversion from Urban Decay. A lot of you seem to love it! =)

I love Inglot's Gel Liner in #77. Matte black with awesome staying power. I wear it on my waterline as well and it does not budge.

Mar 24, 2012

Lacey A.

for liquid maybelline line stilletto is my absolute fav!

Mar 24, 2012

Naomi H.

Pencil: Milani Liquifeye for me

Milani Liquifeye, Urban Decay 24/7 in perversion (both liquid and pencil) and Too Faced Waterproof eyeliner in Perfect Black.

Mar 25, 2012

Jennie A.

I love my MAC fluidline in blacktrack!

Mar 25, 2012

Marianna D.

I like to use the MAC pen eyeliner :) 

Mar 25, 2012

Meechi S.

the elf cream liner :D love it!

Mar 25, 2012

LaKesha L.

Drugstore Eyeliner the best in my opinion is Maybelline Master Drama!! I love this!!!

Mar 25, 2012

Paige L.

Maybelline has great pencils. Only a few companies manufacture eye pencils, so it's a better option to just buy drugstore.

I like Mac's pencil and Urban Decay perversion pencil. For liquid I use loreal linear intense liquid liner.

Mar 25, 2012

Lola T.

I really like gel eyeliner, it's so easy to apply ♥

Mar 25, 2012

Fancie B.

I really like L'Oreal's voluminous smoldering eyeliner in black. It is super dark, easy to smudge before setting and lasts all day. Plus it's like $8!

Mar 25, 2012

Nikelle S.

MAC BLACKTRACK

Mar 27, 2012

Amelia R.

Milani Liquif'eye. It's SO creamy and black and amazing. And if you're willing to pony up the extra bucks, Urban Decay's Perversion is also amazing.

I love Physician's Formula Eye Enhancing Eyeliner. It's the absolute best.