Eyeliner Help!

Mar 13, 2012

Brigitte H.

What are your favorite eyeliners? I want one that will last for a while. I have tried drugstore "waterproof" ones and urban decays waterproof one but they all start to smudge after an hour or two and its really annoying lol

Mar 13, 2012

Ish K.

I had the same problem, but the Maybelline gel eyeliner works for me.

Mar 13, 2012

Erin C.

I agree with Ish on the Maybelline gel liner. I wore it swimming once and it just kind of faded a little bit but it didn't smudge. I find you do need to set it on the waterline if you have watery eyes though. It doesn't smudge but it fades quicker if you don't set it

Mar 13, 2012

keri k.

i use mac fluidline, it last me all day without smudging and my eyes are normally quite watery too. 

Mar 13, 2012

Christine R.

i use the master precise eyeliner pen by maybelline. hasn't smudged on me and I wear it all day. 

Mar 13, 2012

Theresa K.

I bought a L'oreal infalible eye pencil on a whim (it was on sale for like $3) and I REALLY like it. The only thing I hate is that it's a twist up one, so you can never get a sharp point. But it lasts! It was a pleasant surprise! Otherwise if you wanna be luxurious, I LOVE Estee Lauders double wear pencils. FAN-TASTIC!

Mar 14, 2012

Amanda J.

NYX glide on eyeliners are great, and so are the Hot Topic eyeliners. Not the warpaint ones, the ones that are the silver packaging with the fishnet pattern... Those ones are fantastic. Both are kind of hard to find (obviously at hot topic, and you can find the NYX eyeliners at Ulta), but both are really cheap. :)

Mar 14, 2012

Sharie S.

i just bought the elf cream or gel eyeliner. it was like 3 bucks online and it lasts really long. i had a hard time getting it off yesterday.

Mar 14, 2012

Heather M.

I've been swearing by Lorac's Front of the Line pro, it's a liquid liner pen and hasn't dried up on me yet (I've had it for a couple months now). Now if only they made more colors.... :sigh:

Mar 14, 2012

Shruti A.

My three favorite's would be Mac fluidline, Inglot gel liners or Lancome artliner. anytime I use those three my liner never smudges or fades

Mar 14, 2012

Veronica B.

I like Bobbi Brown gel liner, literally doesn't smudge at all! But for my waterline I like UD 24/7 glide on pencil. 

Mar 14, 2012

Rebekah D.

Revlon Colorstay is the longest wearing eyeliner i've tried. 

Mar 14, 2012

Brittany Y.

I went to ulta and swatched like 15 eyeliners on my hand and didn't wash my hand in the shower that night and the next morning I woke up to see the NYX eyeliners stayed bright and visible on my hand. 

Mar 14, 2012

Ingrid N.

I would say Maybelline Gel Liner. It's definitely comparable to Bobbi Brown's gel liner and Mac's fluid line but much much more affordable. Lasts the whole day but on days when I feel extra precautious, I seal it in with a matte black eyeshadow and it's fullproof. Definitely a HG product for me.

Mar 14, 2012

Alexirisha G.

I bought a cheap liquid liner from a dollar store and it works great.

Mar 17, 2012

Lizz N.

i like the maybelline master precise eyeliner. it lasts forever... it only smudges when i sleep in it haha (which is bad anyway lol) 

Mar 29, 2012

Brigitte H.

Thank you so much everyone!! I'll try some of the drugstore ones first and see how they go!

Mar 31, 2012

Dawn M.

Wet n Wild Gel eyeliner... or Avon Glimmersticks eyeliner are my 2 favorite Go To eyeliners!! Couldn't live without them!!