Which Benefit Mascara?

Aug 5, 2017

Sarah L.

I'm thinking of purchasing either the "They're real" or "Roller lash" mascara by Benefit. I tend to use waterproof mascaras due to the fact that I wear contacts and my lashes aren't curled at all and waterproof mascaras tend to hold the curl better. Which one would you recommend for my straight not to long lashes.

Aug 5, 2017

Sarah L.

I want something volumising that hold a good curl and doesn't transfer.

Aug 5, 2017

Lenox-mae R.

I've never used Roller Lash, but I've used a dupe for it that people say is exactly like it. And I've also used They're Real. They're Real I find is better for lengthening rather than curling and adds good volume. My dupe for Roller Lash (which is Essence Lash Princess by the way), is very good at lengthening and curling, but doesn't add much volume. They're Real for me didn't transfer too much. I hope this helps!

Aug 6, 2017

Aleena P.

I wasn't a fan of either. they're real left my lashes hard and crispy and flaked. it gave decent length and definition but not a lot of volume and my lashes looked spikey.
roller lash also left my lashes hard and crispy and did better giving them volume but was nothing extraordinary and the curved brush drove me nuts.
my favorite at the moment is marc Jacobs velvet noir

Aug 6, 2017

Mila V.

I used the they're real and I didn't really like it because it really separated my lashes.

Aug 6, 2017

Lara R.

I have the same kind of lashes, which do not hold the curl. None of the Benefit maacaras helped with that issue.

My favorite mascara is Covergirl Supersizer. Although it's not branded as waterproof, it does an amazing job holding the curl and adding length