Witch Hazel/Rose Water Or Toner?

14

Sort By

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

Happy Easter lovelies! :)
I was thinking about my skin care routine and I'm very happy with it. My only question is do you think witch hazel or rose water would be better for my skin (dry skin) over my toner?
I'm currently using Neutrogena Alcohol Free Toner and it leaves my skin so hydrated,I love it.
But I think its time to try something new.
Which would you suggest? What are you opinions?
Thanks again! Oh btw I tried oil cleansing. If you have any questions ask below or I can do a post of you want.

Apr 5, 2015

Kitty K.

Rose water is actually just a light fragrance, providing no benefit to the skin although marketted as beneficial for profit.
If you have dry skin, I recommend using Aloe Vera juice instead. Far more beneficial and contains salicylic acid occuring naturally... helps with redness, inflmmation, and helps attract moisture to the skin.

Apr 5, 2015

Demetria S.

I use this. But I have oily acne prone skin. I use it in my routine regularly and I have seen a huge difference. My dark spots are gone, my skin is brighter and really fresh. I live by this stuff. It took a few weeks to start seeing drastic results.

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@kitty oh wow okay, ill look into that @Demetria seems like everything I'm looking for lol I'll definitely check it out @Jocelyn I'm happy it worked for you :)

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@Reny I'm off Indian descent and my aunt uses it and she's was talking about it that why I'm interested in it

Apr 5, 2015

Demetria S.

Reny. What benefits do people mostly get? I wonder if the one I'm using is giving me all the great benefits :)

Apr 5, 2015

Kitty K.

@Reny Do you have any published articles on it? My skin esthetician and derm has mentioned it being a fragrance and essentially useless. I am not sure if you follow Veronica Gorgeious who is a skin esthetician as well, but she has also mentioned it being just fragrance. I am curious about it, although skeptical because I have not achieved any benefits from it other than smelling nice.

Apr 5, 2015

Demetria S.

Thank you Reny. I'll keep using the one I have

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@Reny thanks for the advice and its nice to meet one of my fellow desi :) @demetria where did you buy the thayers witch hazel?

Apr 5, 2015

Demetria S.

I got it at my local organic market (MOMS). I'm not sure where you are but they have several locations in the US. They also have a website that you can purchase from. Thayers.com

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@Demetria thanks for the info :)

Apr 5, 2015

Kitty K.

Thanks Reny

You can get the Thayers at GNC, Vitamin Shoppe, or Whole Foods. I suggest making sure its unfiltered and alcohol free so you get the full benefits. I use these two and mix them with my Aztec Healing Clay

Apr 5, 2015

Demetria S.

No problem Sheerise :)

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@kitty thanks I'll definitely look into these products :)

Apr 5, 2015

Shelley W.

My skin loves aloe vera toner and rose water. After my fave from Mario Badsecu was re-formulated into utter garbage I was told to go to an Indian store as well for rose water. It doesn't dry out my skin and is great at removing residual product after cleansing the skin. I wish I discovered it years ago because its better than Mario Badescu.

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@shelly that's good to know. I'm happy it worked for you

Apr 5, 2015

Kailey L.

I love rose water as a toner! My skin is much more balanced since I started using it.

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@Kailey okay, do you use a organic one?

Apr 5, 2015

Kailey L.

I do! Mine is straight 100% rose water. It's Alteya Organics Organic Bulgarian Rose Water. And it comes in a fine mist spray bottle, which I love.

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@Kelly ohhh sounds nice

Apr 5, 2015

Angela J.

I mix rose water, witch hazel and glycerin in a spray bottle:) Then shake and spray! I love it and keep it in the fridge in summer to make it extra refreshing. Perfect for my dry acne prone skin.

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@Angela ooh that sounds refreshing lol.. I hear a lot about Glycerin what is the purpose of it?

Apr 5, 2015

Shelby P.

I think it depends on what is being classified as rose water. If you're using a Rose Hydrolat or:

" A hydrosol, also known as floral water or hydrolat, is the aromatic water that contains both water soluble plant components and very small amounts of essential oil. This is the solution that remains after an essential oil is distilled via steam distillation."

then there are definitely proven benefits to it's use. Rose essential oil is highly touted as being therapeutic particularly with our skin. Roses themselves are not just perfume or fragrance, they're a medicinal plant. Here's an article discussing this:

http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/2633703

Apr 5, 2015

Shelby P.

Most witch hazel in grocery stores contain a high amount of alcohol, which I personally choose to avoid in skin care products. A witch hazel hydrolat is what I use. I order through Plant Therapy but I'm sure there are other places to buy them!

Apr 5, 2015

Sheerise M.

@Shelby thanks for info I'll keep that in mind :)