Needing the perfect mascara after One by One discontinued!

Mar 1, 2015

Bri-bri L.

My only favourite maybelline one by one mascara waterproof got discontinued! :( Please suggest me a mascara that:
-is a drugstore mascara
-has a waterproof version
-holds a curl
-doesn't smudge or flake too much
-lengthens (I don't really like volume)
-isn't too hard to take off

Or tell me a mascara that you like or had good luck with! :)

Mar 1, 2015

Ashley D.

Great Lash, the rocket, butterfly mascara (not sure of the name, it's by loreal) are the ones I used when I used drugstore mascara

Mar 1, 2015

J L.

I love Loreal intenza butterfly mascara it's amazing both lengthening and volumizing. If you want a mascara with a lot of length I recommend Loreal telescopic mascara both 5 he grey and black tube are great! (:

Mar 1, 2015

Ariana G.

I like Revlon Dark Lacquer mascara because it gives great length and the brush is amazing on it. Maybelline Pumped Up Volume mascara givea ridiculous volume and length. And Wet N Wild Blackest Black mascara is so black and I use it as a final coat of mascara with Maybelline Pumped Up and it really defines lashes.

Mar 1, 2015

Ashley D.

Jordana best lash extreme volumizing mascara is also really good for length, even though it doesn't seem like it.

Mar 1, 2015

J L.

I wonder why they discontinued the one by one? It was such a great mascara. I'm pretty sure that was my very first makeup item/mascara.

Mar 1, 2015

Gretel T.

We still have it! Maybe we could do a makeup swap??

Mar 1, 2015

Anissa J.

Bourjois has great mascara or cover girl

Mar 1, 2015

Maryellen O.

I'm loving the new Benefit Roller Lash.. Truly curls and stays on.

Mar 1, 2015

Gloria G.

Loreal telescopic hands down for sure

Mar 1, 2015

Gloria G.

The black bottle*

Mar 2, 2015

Codi R.

Loreal telescopic is most like one by one

Mar 2, 2015

Allie W.

Maybelline the falsies

Mar 2, 2015

Gisell G.

Drugstore I like the maybelline falsies waterproof one & loreal telescopic.

Mar 2, 2015

Mariah V.

My favorite drug store mascara is great lash 😍😍 omg it's the best and gives great length and doesn't clump. Trust me you should definitely purchase it😊

Mar 2, 2015

Lucy M.

Chanel mascara in number 10. I can't fault it, I've been through 3 tubs, it lengthens and thickens but not like spiders webs, get a sample from the makeup counter, I can't live without it.