Benefit's they're real: mega clumps

17

Sort By

Jan 31, 2013

Francoise B.

Hmmm I'm not sure if its just me, but has anyone noticed how the Benefit's they're real mascara sends you to clump city? I'm really trying to love this mascara but it just gives me way too much clumps. Any tips/tricks to put it on to avoid clumping? Thanks a lot ;)

Jan 31, 2013

Ave M.

Ya I hate benefits mascaras. There's way better drugstore ones.

Jan 31, 2013

Francoise B.

Ave M. What drugstore brands can you suggest? Something that thickens and holds the curl all day? Thanks ;)

Jan 31, 2013

Pamela F.

i found it awful.waste of money.max factors false lash effect is amazing.and so os the l'oreal one thats double ended (elixer in one side,mascara the other) cnt remember what its called....

Jan 31, 2013

Rachel M.

Put it ( with lid closed) a mug of hot water and leave it for a few hours. Works for me

Jan 31, 2013

Chloe L.

You need to let it dry out a bit I always leave the top off mine for a day before I start using a new one 

Jan 31, 2013

Sahar R.

not a good mascara at allll. in drugstore, Try ALMAY get up and grow. high end try dior- the newest one - it is the blackest black. love it.

Jan 31, 2013

Katelynn D.

I actually liked it! I have naturally straight shortish lashes and found it worked well for lengthening and the brush helped give me some curl. I prefer my mascara a bit drier as well, I usually only apply lightly the first few times. For this particular mascara I had clumps when I first used it because I applied it like a basic mascara. But then I realized this mascara is supposed to build up your lashes, so the formula is thicker, so I tried applying differently with great results! When I use this now, I make sure none of my lashes are tangled or overlap, then put the wand at the very base of my lashes (as close to eye w/o touching as you can, I suggest waterline) then very slowly pull the wand through your lashes while gently turning the wand counter clockwise toward the ground. The slow prevents clumps, the turning aids the curling process and makes the liquid go on evenly instead of all at once.

*I didn't have to purchase mine, but I might get more when my sample runs out. Really the technique changed everything. On the first layer each stroke takes me about four seconds, after that I just touch up spots that need more. 

Jan 31, 2013

Francoise B.

Thanks ladies. For letting me know your thoughts with they're real, with Katelynn D. I'll try to do your trick before I finally give up with it, one last try. Lol. Thanks again ;)

Jessica S.

Jan 31, 2013

Jessica S.

I use that mascara every day. It took me a little while to get used to it also. But i love it. I found it starts clumping when its getting to when you need a new one. I think its great. I layer it over other mascaras. For added length. 

Jan 31, 2013

Francoise B.

Thanks Jessica S. ;)

Feb 1, 2013

Corinna A.

i always use max factor 2000 calorie can never find one that beats that! 

Feb 1, 2013

Ave M.

Cover girl lash blast isn't terrible. Certain almay mascaras are ok too. I use tartes lash hugger and macs dazzle lash (which isn't great).

I'm super picky about mascaras and all the ones I loved in highschool have been discontinued. Still on the search for my holly grail.

Feb 1, 2013

Katelynn D.

Awesome! Hope it works for you, if not I hope you find the one for you!

Feb 1, 2013

Dena M.

If this is happening to you, it might be due to the product being too old and it might mean you need to change your tube. Also, a great tip to try is wiping the wand off with a paper towel as soon as you open it. Or try using a lash primer to help protect your lashes and give the other lash product flexibility. Other than that, I'm not too sure. I have straight VERY short lashes and I find this product works really great. Good luck.

Feb 1, 2013

Francoise B.

Thanks Dena, I'll try to do your trick. Hope it helps ;)

Feb 2, 2013

Drea L.

It definitely starts to clump up for me after a 2 coats. It's too watery for my liking. I'll still use it but eh

Feb 2, 2013

Natalie W.

For me, less is more. I only brush it in my lashes about 5 times, 1 coat only. 

Feb 2, 2013

Natalie W.

*brush it on

Feb 2, 2013

Jessica S.

I am not a fan of that mascara, but I find using an eye lash primer (looks white like if you're unsure) helps tremendously with clumping. I have long lashes and they always clump with this, but after using a primer, it's clump free and even longer length than with the mascara alone! 

I really want to love it, but I'm not too amazed by it either. It does an okay job, but I still layer another mascara over it for a more dramatic effect.

Feb 2, 2013

Nelsy M.

For a cheap and quick fix: dip a q- tip in baby oil and dab on lashes. It stops mascara from clumping :) Just dont put on too much.

Feb 2, 2013

Virginia M.

I liked it, but there are a lot better and cheaper ones at the drugstore

Feb 2, 2013

Francoise B.

Nelsy M. That's a new tip ie never heard of, gotta try that one. Thanks ;) Virginia M. Yeah most people say there are a lot better mascaras out there, I heard revlon's 3d photo ready does a good job ;)