I'm really impressed with this eyeliner. It's very pigmented and I like that it comes with a sharpener and a smudger. I also bought this in Aqua Sparkle & Emerald Sparkle and the colour payoff is great for all of them! It doesn't budge at all for a whole day. I also tried tightlining and waterlining with this and it lasted all day except for some fading at the outer corner of my waterline - but that's only because of my eye shape. Overall, I love this so much and I will definitely repurchase, perhaps in some other colours too.
I own this retractable eyeliner in the waterproof version. It is amazing. I have been on the search for a good waterproof eyeliner that would tight line my eyes and would be soft, last all day, not smear or smudge, and would really be WATERPROOF. I have tried many drug store eyeliners and the UD 24/7 liner. Its the top of the line drug store waterproof eyeliner and its even better then my UD 24/7 liner because my UD one smears and does not last all day. The rimmel one never has to be sharpened and it really is great and affordable ($4-5) I can not rave enough about it (and it comes with a built in smudger and sharpener on one end). I recommend it!!
I've used Revlon Colorstay 16-hour eyeliner for YEARS until my sister told me about Rimmel's Exaggerate Eye Definer. I've been using it for the past 3 months and I couldn't be happier! It goes on really dark and hardly ever needs a touch-up throughout the day. No smudges, great lines, and is very cheap in comparison to other eye liners out there. To all eyeliner connoisseurs out there, put this product in your toolkit!
Amazing Wal-Mart eyeliner
I have just recently started using this amazing water proof eyeliner, all other eyeliners i have used all run even if they dont get wet but this one stays on my eyes all day wich is really great it is absolutley amazing :) And when they say its water proof they mean it i took a shower with it on and it was still perfect after
So soft - best drugstore eyeliner!
This is probably something that is just one step behind the high end eyeliners. It's so soft, the packaging is small and easy to carry around. It's blendable if you'd like, but it also stays put. The only place it doesn't stay put is on the waterline - it slides down to your lashline but it stays there, so it's not horrible. You will never look like a panda! However, if you get the ones with the sponge end, that part is quite shite. That being said, for the price, it's probably just one step behind the likes of MAC's kohl liner cuz that one stays on your waterline. It's also so soft that I go through these every 3 months or so, so I've switched to the pencil kind.