I absolutely love this cream eyeliner. I used another brand before, high-end, and I very much prefer a simple $3.00 eyeliner over that one any day. In fact, I felt that the E.L.F. one has a far better staying power than the high-end one. The pigmentation is there, and it lasts 8+ hours on me without fading or smudging.
Couldn't have asked for more for the price
I love how pigmented it is and it goes on very smooth. It has a great price of $3, so if you try it and don't like, you didn't waste anything. It comes with a small angle brush thats easy to use but I would recommend using a full size brush to have a steady hand. Overall, I love it.
It is a great product. Smaller than I expected because of the photo. It glides on smooth and it's also very pigmented. I am also happy it came with an angled brush! But the brush is smaller than I would have expected, also. It's smaller than the regular angled brush by e.l.f (Studio Line; $3).
The only real problem I had was this:
"SMUDGE-PROOF, BUDGE-PROOF and WATER-RESISTENT coverage for all day..." While as it was a great product, it did smudge a tad bit. It also isn't water resistant, nor did it stay on all day. But if you use an eye primer on your waterline (where I usually put this), I'm pretty sure it will stay on! Or if you set it with powder. :)
Can't get enough!
I was a little skeptical on using an other liner than Mac's liquid liner but I am so happy I tried it. Goes on smoothly and stays on! I was surprised of how well it stayed on for me. Great for a cat eye and on the water line. I have one for myself and black and brown for my kit. I do not use the brush it came with though.