This will get it all off and is really gentle on the eyes. Baby shampoo burns more than this stuff! I had bought a tub of this when I was younger and thought I didn't like it because I didn't know how to use it properly. Don't use water with this, it won't work. Even rinsing with water won't really work, you have to wipe it all off. Anyway, awesome stuff...I would definitely recommend this to a friend.