Physicians Formula

Eye Definer Felt-Tip Eye Marker

Shop Related Products

Reviews

Neda O.

I loved the applicator it was amazing and VERY precise! But it took a long time to dry so I tried not to blink much after putting it on and it is also VERY HARD to take off the cap when you want to apply. I had a lot of difficulty and eventually ended up using my shirt to take it off...and it did come off...along with completely ruin my shirt. It also dried out very quickly, I probably got a weeks worth of use out of this.

Carly T.
Wish I read the reviews before buying!

My problem is not with the pigmentation, but rather the application brush. It is stiff and not pliable whatsoever. Hard to get a straight line without having a half thick, half thin zig zag mess. I have given this product quite a go (at least one month of trying) and still no success. Move on ladies!

Dani P.
Total Dissapointment

I recently bought this in hopes of having an awesome new felt tip liner. I love all of their other products I have bought. Especially the Cream Liner trio's. This was such a disappointment compared to those. First of all the packaging is overly combersome and completely ridiculous for such a small pen.

Getting past the packaging, the product itself was just lackluster. It swatched great on my hand it made a nice dark black line, and you can make an ultra thin line or thicken it up easily. However when I went to apply it to my eye, it does not want to go on. I don't know if its a problem with the angle or what and product not saturating the felt tip or what, but even after several passes it doesn't go on opaque. It seems to just rub itself away in places.

I gave this 1 and a half stars because the formula is great, it doesn't budge from the swatch on my hand, but if you can't get it to apply to your eye, what good does that really do you?

I was very dissapointed, and would return it if I could. I would definitely pass on this, until they fix the application issue.

Iliana A.
total disappointment.

I bought this eyeliner thinking I was going to love it, but just got disappointment. It dries out before I even finish my eye. It's even worse over eyeshadow, it doesn't even go on. I will say that when I did have it on, it stayed on all day . But I just wish it would apply easier.

Kara K.
Good idea but dried up.

When the product was on sale i thought that it would be perfect for doing "cat eye" but it was already dried up when 1st tried to use it. I threw it away within the 2nd week that i had it.

Jessenia I.
Disappointing

I only got to line half of my lid before the felt-trip dried up and began skipping. I had to put the cap back on and tap it on the desk about seven times so that I could line my lids. I gave it the benefit of the doubt and thought that maybe the tip wasn't absorbing much liquid because it was new and being stored upright in its packaging. After about an hour of wearing the liner, I looked in my compact mirror only to find that I had raccoon eyes! So in this case, the description couldn't be any farther from the truth. This liner did skip and it did smear. =(

1 found this helpful.