I was actually sent this from Beautylish, and when I first opened my little package, I just thought it was a black eyeliner.. but when I found out it was a silver one I was kind of excited to try out a silver eyeliner, since I've never had one before. I have heard that these eyeliners are comparable to the 24-7 liners by Urban Decay... but I will admit I like these much, much better! I couldn't believe how creamy the eyeliner was & how pigmented it is! I was in love! & The staying power is amazing too! I will be buying more of these for sure! They are awesome!