Bought this at walmart and i think i found my holly grail eyeliner beside Revlon. I love the colors collections too. I bought one in Aqua and i bought another one in Black. I use it also as eyeshadows, even though they have the stick eyeshadows collections. But this eye liner could be used for eyeshadow too. Just smudge it with finger and you will get a good result as eyeshadow. LOVE!
Great color and texture
Aqua is a dream to apply: smooth and creamy! The color payoff is great too; like many others have said, I don't need to go over the line for the color to be vibrant. Also, once the liner sets, it stays! There's no creasing or smudging, especially when applied over a primer. Unfortunately, I find that Aqua stains my lids, so I'm not going to give it a full five stars. But I still really like it and will try the other colors as well.