I only own one lip liner so far and it seriously has some kind of weird powers. Like this lip liner is incredibly creamy and not drying at all! The color is super pigmented and stays on all day. I don't have any issues with it transferring off my lips. Definitely going to be buying more in the future!
Pigmentation was very full but it would come off on my oily skin. It smudged easily with food and drink, a problem I didn't have with even Rimmel's lip liners. It's a beautiful shade and hard to dupe though.