ColorStay Liquid Eye Pen

I see almost everybody complaining about this eyeliner, but with all honesty, I actually really liked it.

The felt tip is thin but not too thin. The colour is really black (and does NOT appear grey). It glides on smoothly and I can do a perfect wing with this.

The only problem I have with it is that it doesn't last ALL day. Yes, it lasts quite long (as compared to many other hyped over eyeliners) but I just wish that it lasted the entire day.

Though, it is smudge and water proof.

Overall, I love it!

It was okay, but some things threw me off. It was not pigmented. Using the felt tip was painful. I have this to my mom because she liked it. If you are going for a softer look, this would be fine, and as long as you use less pressure (which leads to less pigment), it won't hurt.

It dried up the 2 day i used ,did not like it at all 🙅❌will try to find a better liquid pen this one is definitely not the one 🚫

I havent had the money to buy the Kat Von D. So i was like "what the heck" and bought this one instead. I honestly think it's better! It doesn't flake and smudge by the end of the day like the Kat Von D because of my ... Oily (?) eyelids. So i might buy my second pen when it runs out!

I was told this was a dupe for Stila's Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner. Man, were they wrong. It smudges so bad. I've actually gotten comments because they eyeliner was- no joke- on my cheek. My lower cheek. Like the person below me said, it does the dry erase marker thing if you go over a line, but it's not very pigmented, so you have to go over the line.

This was the driest eyeliner I've ever used, it drags, it smears, it does that awkward dry erase marker effect where if you go over the same line twice it erases itself- its just all around bad. I've given it more than one try, too. Not a fan.

I don't remember where or when I got this, but when I tried it out at first I hated it. Then I watched a youtube video on how to use liquid eyeliner. They recommended a felt tip, and I decided to use it. I fell in absolute love. I tried it out for a whole day and it stayed on. This is the best liquid eyeliner I've ever had. I definitely recommend this product to everyone.

I really wanted to like this, I thought it'd be a cheap dupe for my Stila pen. However, I bought it and it was kind of drying out (had to keep going over the line i made, which i hate doing haha) so I returned it to Walmart and bought another one. Same deal! Returned, gave it one more chance and bought it AGAIN lol. Used it for about 1 1/2 weeks and it was great. But then it dried out. :( I gave up haha maybe 've just got a bad walmart nearby

I really like this eye liner. It makes using liquid eye liner much easier for me because of the pen tip style. It lasts on my eyes and doesn't wear off.

I love this eyeliner. You can do an easy fool proof cat eye in no time. It lasts all day and yet is easy to take off. Yes, as many as stated, it is not too dark as other eyeliners but you can easily build up to get a darker black.