wonderfully smooth and creamy, just glides on application, zero tugging or pulling on skin. pigmentation is really nice and it lasts all day. does smudge, but it is a pencil eyeliner and it's useful when you want to smoke out a line. perfect for lining the waterline, my eyes don't get irritated at all. pretty sure the formula is paraben-free, I think tocopherol is the preservative used. I want to try out some of the other shades next!
Bought this at walmart and i think i found my holly grail eyeliner beside Revlon. I love the colors collections too. I bought one in Aqua and i bought another one in Black. I use it also as eyeshadows, even though they have the stick eyeshadows collections. But this eye liner could be used for eyeshadow too. Just smudge it with finger and you will get a good result as eyeshadow. LOVE!
This is the blackest eyeliner I have. I love using it as a base for my eyeshadows because it won't crease! It's great to have for a smoked out winged liner because the black is so intense. It's creamy, smooth, and easy to work with. Once it sets it isn't moving. I just wish it would stay in my waterline, but then again UD pencils don't even work for me.
I was amazed at how good this product was, considering the price! It applies so easily, and stays on for hours (and products usually don't last that long on me). So impressed! Fantastic value for money, I just wish I was able to find these products in stores here.
Great for the price
Great value for a drug store product.. Very creamy but borderline too creamy if that makes sense haha.. The liner is very soft and does glide on nicely but the tip of the pencil is so soft that it flatens out quickly and the tip scrapes off on your lashes and leaves clumps of soft liner in your lash line.. The liner is very easy to line your water lines with but can cloud your eyes after applying it since it doesnt quite stay in place right away.. But intense pigment for such a low price
Beat Bobbi Brown
I wish I'd had my camera. About a week ago, my friend and I were at Kmart and I told her how much I love this eyeliner, she told me she already used Bobbi Brown but because it was so inexpensive and she wears eyeliner everyday, she'd try it. I went to her house yesterday and I asked her how it was working for her, and she brings me to her vanity, swatches the Milani liner and then the Bobbi Brown one and I swear, this one was a million times blacker and smoother. You have to try it, you will not be disappointed.
I love these eyeliners so much.
The packaging of these eyeliners says they are smooth with the application and that they are smudge-proof. Well they are both TRUE! They are also very pigmented. They only cause me a problem if I wear them on my waterline, they irritate my eyes. Which is why i didn't purchase the black one, however on my lash line and eyelid i have no problem. I do own all the other four and I'm very happy with them. You should definitely give them a try!!! ( I have a swatch of the eyeliners after rubbing them with my finger several times, and as you can see they are still intact)