Good, but not great
I used this in my waterline, and it worked well, but there was a LOT of fallout that got in my eyes and on my contacts. Not fun. I used it for some time but then I found a better eyeliner that I love! Also, the application is not very sanitary- using the same little wand every time after it's been in your eye. All in all, it's an OK product, but not recommended.