Hello! I just bought this one today in Brunette. I picked this one out because at Ulta there were a few different brands of brow liner but this one was a good weight, it could be sharpened and it was smooth and stayed on my hand. I tried it at home right away and holy creamy! this is the most expensive quality browliner and I do mine everyday. My eyebrows didnt know what to think, It is waxy and gets on the hairs, so THERE IS a purpose for the attached brush it stays, keeps them polished. It does make a difference.