This set was originally 5 bucks, but I got it for 2.50 on the after christmas sale! I love it so much! The liners are really nice! The black is very black, the 2 glitters are packed with glitter! Not sheer like some glitter liners can be- annoying, and the grey is a really pretty shade. The brush is really nice! Thicker than the original hard candy liquid liner, really easy to use! These 4 can make really simple but cute looks! I did my new years look with the black and silver, actually! I'll tag the picture. This is a great product! Definently go look for it at your walmart! It's probably 75% off now!