Love at first siiiight!!!
It truly is waterproof. Once this goes on (and it goes on nice and smoothly, not to mention very dark), it's ON there. I loooove this product. The little smudger at the end of the pencil comes in handy for achieving that smokey look too. Great investment if you wear eyeliner every day like I do and are tired of having to touch it up repeatedly.
Exclusively for my waterline
This was an expensive purchase @ $28 so I reserve it for my waterline only. I use it on top and bottom, it is a bit buildable and takes about 1.5 minutes to dry completely and set. So I usually put it on, do some other makeup and put another 'coat'. It lasts all day/night so I knew it was worth the investment.
Now the removal process takes a q-tip with eye makeup remover - not on my waterline, just my lashline and it takes it off. (I use neutrogena's oil-free eye makeup remover). Even still I usually have raccoon eyes the next morning and have to do the q-tip thing again. lol.
If you check out my profile, there is a video called #408 dior green design, this liner is used in that look.
I gave it a full 5 stars because it does what i says, it's easy, long lasting and best of all - comes with a sharpener! YAY! I would rebuy.