MAC Woodwinked vs. UD Half Baked

Sort By

Nov 21, 2010

Yu A.

Are they similar? What are the differences in terms of colour, texture etc.,? I'm looking for more of a rich gold, and I don't have either of them. I've always wondered if Woodwinked would look too orange on me, and I've never actually swatched Half Baked, but I see it on YouTube and it looks so pretty - are they different enough to justify buying both, or should they be bought as 'dupes'?

Hmm i have both eyeshadows and I think woodwinked is more orange. It looks really pretty though :) I think half baked is more gold then woodwinked. They don't seem similar to me...yesterday I used woodwinked on the lid and half baked in the inner tear ducts. So I dont think they are similar...they both go on buttery smooth and are beautiful colors. Half baked seems to have more shimmer then woodwinked. Hope this helps :) 

Nov 22, 2010

Yu A.

Ahh someone told me the same thing when I asked.. I decided to skip on UD for now, but I can see myself getting it another time. Right now, I do have a gold colour already, but not a bronze. But I guess Woodwinked seems more unique than half-baked.. am I right? Thank you so much for your help! :)

They are not similar to me at all. Half Baked is more of a true gold and Woodwinked is way lighter.

yea woodwinked is more unique. Ud half baked is just a shimmery gold. They both are beautiful though :) I would go with woodwinked if u could only buy one. Hope that helps <3

Log in or join now to add a comment.