What's the best eyeliner to use on your waterline?

19
Sort By

Apr 11, 2012

Rachel W.

I tried many eyeliners to use on my waterline and I can't find one I really love. If you have any suggestions please let me know! Thanks so much :)

Apr 11, 2012

Ameema H.

Urban Decay 24/7 it works well and does not smear. Wet'n'Wild IdolEyes is good :) i use it works all day.

Apr 11, 2012

Robyn S.

L'Oreal HIP eye liner pencil

Apr 11, 2012

Yumi R.

I really like Chanel's kohl pencil if you want something super black and smokey. MAC's Technakohl is another good one :)

Apr 11, 2012

Rachel W.

Thanks everyone :)

Apr 11, 2012

Christina L.

I love MAC's kohl liner...it's super pigmented and stays in place and on pretty long too. I also love Milani's Liquifi liners too. They are super creamy and perfect for smudging on the lower lash line. 

Apr 12, 2012

Terra M.

I have very watery eyes and these are my 3 favorites I always rotate around:
Urban Decay Perversion 24/7 glide on pencil (glides on easy very black and lasts)

Milani liquifyeye (puts down a LOT of very black product, great for smudging, lasts)

Maybelline Master Drama eye liner (perfect for the waterline, glides easily and lasts, not as black as the others but still black)

Apr 12, 2012

Amelia R.

Milani Liquifeye is really good

Apr 12, 2012

Shelly T.

@Ameena...
<<Urban Decay 24/7 it works well and does not smear.>>

For me, these suck in the waterline. (Although it seems Perversion has a different formula, perhaps?)

Anyhoo. My rec would be Prestige Total Intensity. I've also heard good things about Inglot's gel eyeliners in the waterline (they dry fast).

Apr 12, 2012

Terra M.

@Shelly I agree. The 24/7 glide on in zero is barely pigmented and didn't last at all..it was a really slippery formula. I was shocked whenever I would read someone loved it! Perversion seems to be way different! It doesn't feel the same, it doesn't have that same smeary, slippery feeling like the others do.  

i love milani liquifeye

Apr 13, 2012

Fleur W.

If you are looking for an extremely cheap but great quality liner, I suggest Elf's Waterproof eyeliner pen ($1). I use it everyday. The quality is great. Its a liquid liner. Those usually work best on the water line.

Apr 13, 2012

Rina N.

I use the milani eyeliner and it works wonders and I also like the estee lauder eyeliner! :)

Apr 13, 2012

ashley h.

i love that robyn said l'oreal hip pencils! i used this all throughout high school & after for awhile. granted, i did use a lighter to slightly melt it (proceed with caution, duh), & i remember it being great! i've since collected too many black liners so i'm trying to use those up, although i did cave & finally bought another l'oreal one last week.

UD zero; doesn't work for me
stila stingray; doesn't work for me
milani liquif'eye; doesn't work for me
l'oreal extra-intense liquid pencil liner; doesn't work for me, but what i'm using at the current moment.

i just think it depends on how much your eyes water, if you rub at them a lot, etc. all of these end up under my eyes in a big mess by the end of the day or are already faded by the time i'm done with my mascara. i want to try UD's perversion, but i'm not holding my breath.

Apr 14, 2012

Christy D.

I use Rimmel brand and I like it better than the UD I got recently o_O

Apr 15, 2012

Lisa U.

I always stick to Gel Liners, most are Waterproof. Inglot ones are amazing.

Apr 16, 2012

Emily V.

Urban Decay 24/7

Milani Liquif'eye is one of the best I've used and it only cost $2-$3. It is highly pigmented and stays put all day.

Apr 16, 2012

Alexa D.

Illamasque have the best ones!

Apr 16, 2012

Kayli H.

I put the Maybelline gel eyeliner and top it off with black eyeshadow- that makes it last almost too long hahaha

Apr 17, 2012

Andrea S.

I love my trusty MAC Technakohl haha and I always set with black shadow. I've never tried gel liners on the waterline but heard good things.

I love this asian brand called CLIO its like the best it doesn't smudge doesn't move or smear or whatever once it dries on your waterline after lining it twice it stays put and its highly pigmented doesn't irritate the eyes and yup totally worth S$15.

Log in or join now to add a comment.