KVD or Benefit?

8

Sort By

Aug 6, 2015

Emily B.

So I'm looking to invest in an eyeliner, and I'm now stuff between the two. It's KVD tattoo eyeliner and the benefit they're real push up gel liner. I like that they are both pens and I can't stand eyeliners that are applied with a brush because I can't seem to get the precision I am aiming for. Even with hours and days of practice. The color would be black. I'm wondering which one applies easier because I have arthritis in my hands very bad? Also, which has better wear through the day? Finally, which will give a better color? I don't want it to be a dull black, but strong, does that make sense? And definitely not flakey...
Thank you ladies I really appreciate it.  :)

Aug 6, 2015

Maria c.

I have the kvd and I love it I suck at doing winged liner but this makes it a whole lot easier. I usually have to keep going over my eyeliner to make it even on both eyes and it never flakes or picks itself up. I have hooded eyes and it never smudges on me and lasts all day. I totally recoment it.

Aug 6, 2015

Maria c.

*recommend

Aug 6, 2015

Emily B.

Awesome thank you!!

Aug 7, 2015

Breeze T.

The Benefit is not a felt tip liquid liner, so it will apply like a gel liner on a silicone angled brush. it's also less foolproof. if you have arthritis I suggest you use a felt tip liquid liner so you can touch it up with a q-tip when you mess up.

I actually love the benefit one, but I don't think it's what you're looking for.

Aug 7, 2015

Lara R.

I haven't tried the Benefit eyeliner but I own KVD tattoo eyeliner. It is very good, doesn't smudge or flake and is very easy to use :) in my perspective it may not be as pigmented (black black black) as my Inglot gel liner but it is very decent :) in overall I like it a lot

Aug 7, 2015

Lisa S.

KAT VON D HANDS DOWN! I have tried just about every product from benefit besides their foundations and I have never been pleased by any of their products except for the boing concealer. Anyways, KVDs is super black and last all day and stays black from the time I apply it to the time I take it off before bed. Also I find KVDs to be easy to apply. Benefits is a mess in my opinion.

Aug 7, 2015

val p.

I know you are asking for two high end brands but I feel like the Maybelline Stiletto eyeliner would be great for you, I recommend it to everyone and the reason behind it is because I am VERY Unsteady applying eyeliner and I've always struggled until I got this particular one-- it changed the way I do eyeliner, it's a long felt tip and it gets a lot of coverage at once. It's super helpful! Trust me~ I have arthritis and joint pain, doing a cat I
Eye with this is a breeze!

Aug 7, 2015

val p.

Also, I now don't have to use this eyeliner anymore , I've learned to adapt to others after I used it.. I would buy it but it's 11bucks where I live xD I just get the $3 wet n wild gel liner now

Aug 7, 2015

megan l.

I love they maybelline stiletto seriously use it everyday!

Aug 7, 2015

Roz X.

Kat...but I'd check.out Stila as well.

Aug 7, 2015

Emily B.

Thank you so much. I'll look into those other brands as well.