My True Love

I LOVE LOVE LOVE this eyeliner! It goes on so easily and it is true long wear. It doesn't start to fade throughout the day and it doesn't clog up when you put it on. A definite must buy, especially to only be $3. It's up there with the top brands.

cheap

It's a cheap product. You do get what you pay for. It's a pretty smooth application. Not that black. You will have to build on the colors or just use a black eye shadow on top. Overall it's an okay product.

not loving it

well i got this in my nearest kmart for $1.86 or something that`s why i decided to try it out because it was a really nice deal (i`m a cheap person) well any who.. i tried it out but it wasn`t really working for me i`m not sure if it was just my jar or any one else `s that was dry too but elf really let me down on this product ..as for there other products they are way better

Did not like at all

I had read reviews on how great these gel liners were and I was in the market for a new brown eyeliner and the E.L.F. one was truly a disappointment for me. I find the color when swatched looks okay and then when I wear it on the waterline, it tends to bleed out on me, which is very rare for a gel liner - I've used Mac Fluidline, Physician's Formula gel liner, the Maybelline gel liner and the Wet n' Wild one and none of them bleed on me. As well when I wear it on the upper lash line, it's like the liner never sets and it transfers everywhere, I know I could set it with a powder but once again I've never had to do it with any previous gel/cream liners that I've owned. I really wanted to like this product but it was a big fail for me. I'm not sure if I got a "dud", but I don't believe that I could recommend this liner, when there are other great options at the drug store. Another big disappointment for me was that the brown was not dark enough for me - this is just a personal preference, but I felt that it was worth mentioning.

Great price, great product

I'm a huge fan of e.l.f., always will be. This stuff is pretty good! I usually don't have time to go all out with my make-up, but when I do, I use this stuff. It glides on smooth and doesn't smudge too easy, so it lasts all day! I also like the brush it comes with, because for some strange reason it's harder than ever to find an angled brush in this area. Great for the winged eye look!

Love it!

It goes on smoothly and doesn't wipe off during the day. The color was nice. I overall really enjoyed this product!! I would definitely recommend to everyone I know. :)

I really enjoy these and how they dont rub off! for the price its super good quality! I hated the brush that came with it but no big deal, i just used the one that i have for gel liner!

Great for what I need it for

I have the teal, bright purple, and black ones. I have had the teal the longest which is about 5 months probably. It hasn't dried out on me yet knock-on-wood. I love it and allows for the perfect pop of color on the upper eyelid!!

I love this cream eye liner is goes on smoothly and easy and it very affordable I have it black but I am also going to buy it in brown and the green color.so glad I purchased this!

great for a low price

i have one in coffee and i also have one in black i really like them both. they go one creamy which is nice because they don't pull on your eyelids and you are able to get a nice smooth line. However, mine did seem to dry up pretty fast. I did add a little water to my brush and it still seemed to work fine, i just wish i didn't have to do that.