From skeptic to believer.

I was very hesitant to buy this liner because I bought another cheap, drugstore liner in the past & it was awful...but NYC had impressed me before, so I gave it a go. AND LOVED IT. The formula is so smooth and I absolutely love the applicator. I apply a black shadow over it to set it & my liner lasts all day, even through a 12-hour workday! And the price is what, like $3.00? Awesome buy.

great one worth trying!

I love NYC liquid liner, its not only very inexpensive but also the quality is pretty good. It has felt tip applicator which make it easier to apply, very black and smudge proof. In my opinion it is comparable to Urban decay liquid liner (which is used to be my favorite) but of course NYC is much...better because of the price, who does not like a bargain! :)

great one worth trying!

I love NYC liquid liner, its not only very inexpensive but also the quality is pretty good. It has felt tip applicator which make it easier to apply, very black and smudge proof. In my opinion it is comparable to Urban decay liquid liner (which is used to be my favorite) but of course NYC is much...better because of the price, who does not like a bargain! :)

nice

this is nice for liquid eyeliner that is affordable and long lasting. the only thing i do not like about it is that it is very slow to dry. the first time i put it on and opened my eyes, when i closed the again, i had a ring running straight through my eyeshadow and i couldn't cover it up with more eyeshadow so i just ended up redoing it

Awesome!

I think this is the best most affordable liquid liner available in drugstores! Its matte and really black! I'm not the biggest fan of the applicator but I just use a different brush with it. The formula is amazing! I've never had any problems with it smudging or chipping off which can happen with a lot of liquid liners :) It stays on from start to finish!

great!!

I heard that this eyeliner was one of Megan Fox's favorites so since it was so cheap I had to check it out. It is amazing! I love how thin the applicator is so you can make a really precise line. It stays put almost all day unless I come in contact with water, then it just washes out.

I loved how opaque this applied, but it would never stay. It always flaked off and was not at all waterproof. The applicator did not give very good control so my eyes never matched.

Cheap but excellent!

This eyeliner may just be a dollar but it's one of my favorite eyeliners. It comes on smoothly and it's the right shade. I was using a eyeliner that was too shiny but this eyeliner was dark black.

This was one of the first liquid eyeliners I've used. It's a nice formula and it came out nice and dark. However, it didn't really last the whole day, and the brush was too long for me to work with. Other than that though, it is a great eyeliner and would probably purchase again if they don't have the one I like available.

Very nice for the price!

I've been using this eyeliner for about 7 months now and in love with it!!! I switched to this after using Maybelline Ultra Liner pretty much all throughout high school. I would choose this any day over Maybelline! It goes on smooth and dark, no need to go over anything. The brush may take awhile to get used to but I'm pro by now! Winging the eyeliner is as easy as pie. However, I have noticed that the wing part may fall off before the day is done but I still love it !!!!