I love their clear one, so I thought I'd get a waterproof mascara from them....

MIss, miss, misss....the brush itself isn't great to apply this mascara on my lashes, it completely goes so uneven. Being waterproof is the only thing that held up to it's product name. My lashes didn't stay curled, it didn't give me volume, it just felt like clumps of goo on my lashes. I was so upset because I was in a rush, so I thought this would be a fast fix for me, but I guess not:( I still love their clear lash mascara, I use it for my brows:)

OMG LOVE THIS

This is my favorite mascara EVER! It is really waterproof (as it says) and holds a curl. It only smudges a little but only on hot days (idk why) It gives you a natural lash look as opposed to MAYBELLINE VOLUM' EXPRESS THE FALSIES WATERPROOF, so overall I LOVE this mascara!

A classic

This was one of my first mascaras. I don't really like it that much. Specially when there's better brushes and formulas now. It didn't really separate that good and didn't give a lift. It was never dark enough for me either. I recommend it for girls that are barely starting to wear makeup. It's easy to learn with this one and it's not so dramatic.

Best Drug Store Mascara!

I love love love this! The tiny brush allows me to reach every lash. Even the bottom lashes too. I use this a lot in the summer when I go swimming or want more of a natural look without a lot of eye makeup.

I love how this mascara is waterproof! It pretty much lasts all day (on me it does), and my eyes water constantly during the day (and I also have gym at the end of the school day). My sister had bought this for my for Christmas because she knew I needed new mascara. I absolutely love it and I'm glad she bought it for me.

AMAZING FOR LESS

i think this is the best mascara I've had so far and it works so well i always use this mascara and if it's empty i am sure I'm gonna purchase again it's not expensive so go buy it it's worth it hun

Great and Inexpensive

I love this mascara. It has a great price and it lasts. It is one of my favs and is always in my makeup bag. Even if you like more expensive mascaras this is a great one if you are in a bind and only near a wal mart etc.

Stays on (a little too long)

Definitely waterproof! I couldn't get it off with my normal cleanser or vaseline (my go to when my face wash fails). I had the same application on for 2 days until it wore off. So I'd recommend this for people who don't care about it lasting a long time (maybe on a beach trip and don't want to worry about your mascara everyday) or for those who like their waterproof mascara truly resistant.

This is a great version of the original mascara and I always tend to go back to this mascara when I'm in a bind and need an inexpensive mascara that will keep and work well on my lashes. The Maybelline Great Lash Mascara is an oldie but goodie!

A GOOD STAYING POWER!

I have always had the problem of smudging mascara, so I decided to test this one out. My first impression when using this was that the brush is very nice. It's small enough to get every single lash and gives nice definition. But it doesn't really do anything amazing to your lashes. I don't think that it lengthens and it defiantly doesn't give you much volume! But I do actually kinda like that it does give you a natural look 'cause I've been blessed with naturally very long lashes. But if you prefer the falsies look this maybe isn't the mascara for you!

It stays on all day long and looks very fresh even when you've worn it for 14 hours (which probably isn't too healthy for your lashes! OH WELL!) You do need a good eye makeup remover to get it off but if you have that it's very easy to get off!

I have worked out with this mascara and it did stay on! The grand test I had with it was at my hot yoga class where the temperature is about 100F and it stayed on!