I have an old one of these in yellow. I guess it's been discontinued. I pulled it out because I need help covering undereye circles. It works very well.
It was good. And it definitely did the job. But it stopped doing the job when it broke ... I was putting it on when morning and it snapped right off and went crumbling down my shirt! ... I was upset, but I was upset because it was a good product and now I couldn't use it. I've found a different product that I like better than this, but it was good while it lasted.
Definitely does the job.
This is a great product. I am, if you haven't found out by now, a huge Maybelline fan. It's under $5, sold almost everywhere, and conceals wonderfully. I wouldn't recommend it for under your eyes if you have fine lines, and I do, because it gets in there and makes them more noticeable. Try their concealer in the wand tube for that area. I would repurchase this product!