Am I missing something here?

I use black liner only occasionally when I wear false eyelashes but I prefer a dark brown liner on a everyday basis. I like very dark brown liners because they are a bit softer and work better for my skin tone. I've heard some rave reviews about this eyeliner's pigmentation. The Jordana brown I thought was going to be a dark brown as I saw in reviews online. But after buying it I found that it is watery, reddish and not pigmented at all! So my question is, did I receive a bad one or do I need to give some time and leave it stored upside down for a while; will the formula change? I heard somewhere that is what some people do.

Good felt tip liner but not my thing, at least not yet.

My friend suggested this to me when I asked her what she used to do her awesome winged liner, about a year ago. She told me she got it from Walgreens, she loved it and swore by it, and told me I had to have it! When I got it I was under the impression the brand was called InColor and it was not until sort of recently I discovered it was Jordana brand- a brand I've been wanting to try out for awhile now- go figure, it was right under my nose all along. When I used it I didn't really like the marker feeling to it and much preferred my UD liquid liner that has a brush. My wings were wiggly wobbly so maybe I subconsciously wrote the liner off from there. I got the brown shade and while super pigmented and dark, I wish it looked more noticeably brown. Someday I might be more into pen liners and I might go back to these because they are GREAT if you're into pen liners. I had hung onto this for more than a year and swatched it from time to time to see when the ink ran out- and while it has a little now, it stayed wet for what seems like eons! If you keep it upside down you'll insure the liquid stays in the tip. Plus it was super pigmented, the cap shut tight, and it was cute looking.

So, I'm more of a brush liquid liner type, but I would definitely recommend, like my friend did, this liner to anyone that specifically prefers the pen-type of liquid liner, or noobies who are just starting to play with making wings. The price is right too! Just because I don't use it doesn't mean its a crappy product- its quite the opposite in fact!

Awesome!

I have been using Stila's felt pen eyeliner and although very good, the cost outweighed the benefits. A cashier at my local Walgreens recommended this stuff and I am so glad she did! It goes on smooth, has great lasting color when applied with a shadow base and only costs like 2 bucks a pop. It isn't waterproof like the Stila eyeliner but I haven't had any issues with it running or smearing throughout the day. Highly recommend this product of you want the same look as expensive brands but don't want to pay the price!

Better than most other pen-liners

Some times products isn't worth their price, that has been my experience with a some higher end products. This is way cheaper than any of the Milani and Maybelline pen-liners, and actually much better. The last Milani liner i had dried out in a month with only a few uses :/ My first pen-liner from Maybelline lasted me nearly a half year, but the pigmentation was bad. Now i just got the new pen-liner MasterPrecise, because my Jordana Pen-liner has gotten a bit dry, after everyday use for around 5 months. I already miss using the FabuLiner, it's soo good, and so black, and amazingly long wearing. I'll get another one soon, because the Maybelline MasterPrecise isn't nearly as good as the FabuLiner.
I'll recommend this for all, because of the price, quality and how easy it is to use :)

Recently discovered this little gem...

My problem with felt-tip liners has always been that the VERY tip of the felt tends to carry less and less of the actual product with time...I haven't experienced that yet with this one. For $1.99 @ Walgreens, i'm a happy camper :)

My favourite liner!

I really love the felt tip on this! I can do the most perfect cat eyes from thin to super thick! It does dry out kinda fast but it's only 1.99 at Walgreen's so no biggie. The one draw back for me is, now during my allergies my eyes water and it doesn't come in waterproof. :( So I am looking for something similar in a waterproof formula.
Any suggestions?

Best eyeliner ever.. specially if you are new to the liquid eye liner concept is a good way to get used to it and practice the winged eye... Totally in love with it!!!

Impressed

I absolutely love this liner! I wish I would have tried it sooner. The price is great and the quality of this liner is beyond amazing. I have no need for another liquid/marker liner.

Love this stuff

I have this one in Black and I absolutely love it. Its my favorite liquid liner: easy to use, stays on all day, does not smear off, good pigmentation, only 2 bucks. My con would have to be that it dries out faster then a regular liquid liner (because of the felt-tip pen form) and that its only sold at Walgreens and only at the ones that have a makeup counter :/ but other then that for 2 bucks its not bad at all!! *tip: if you shake it well before each use you get the best pigmentation and it will last longer*

I really enjoy using this eyeliner. It has a nice tip for a thin line or you can use the side to make a thicker line. I do notice that after a long day of wear (when my face becomes a bit oily) the eyeliner smears if I were to rub the side of my eye (I usually do a cat eye and I don't set with a black shadow). I purchased mine at Walgreens and the Jordana Cosmetics are usually next to the Cosmetics cashier.