Beauty Product Reviews

Am I missing something here?

I use black liner only occasionally when I wear false eyelashes but I prefer a dark brown liner on a everyday basis. I like very dark brown liners because they are a bit softer and work better for my skin tone. I've heard some rave reviews about this eyeliner's pigmentation. The Jordana brown I thought was going to be a dark brown as I saw in reviews online. But after buying it I found that it is watery, reddish and not pigmented at all! So my question is, did I receive a bad one or do I need to give some time and leave it stored upside down for a while; will the formula change? I heard somewhere that is what some people do.