Stila

Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner

Reviews

Emily B.
beware contact lens wearers!!
Photo of product included with review by Emily B.

This is an excellent waterproof liner for those of you out there gifted with perfect eyesight (or who prefer to wear glasses). It really is smudge proof, the color Damsel is a lovely dark brown, and it applies smoothly with minimal tugging.

However: for those who wear contacts, this eyeliner is sadly not a good option for you (unless you’re comfortable with hazy blurry vision in one or both eyes). I went through six pairs of contacts (in two days!) before realizing that the constantly appearing cloudy smudge on my contact lenses was the result of this eyeliner. It doesn’t come off with cleaning, soaking or rubbing the lens - the smudge is there to stay, just as it is on your eyelid. I do tightline my upper waterline so it’s possible that keeping the liner on your lid/upper lash line only will keep your contacts safe, but consider carefully before buying!! Attached is a photo of a lens that I wore today for a few hours.

2 found this helpful.