Now, I haven't tried others in this line, but this Hippie Chic lipstick is awful. Sure, it's creamy, but it applies patchy. The only thing matte about it is the lack of shine or glitter. It feels more like a cream lipstick. I tried it over liner, lip primer, and it still wouldn't apply right. I just couldn't get the thing to work. This is probably my first miss with NYX.