MAKE UP FOR EVER

Smoky Lash

Reviews

Nicole A.
very bad

I bought this from sephora during the Rouge sale and it is one of the worst mascaras I've ever used. 1st off it does nothing for length besides not being black enough it's also very dry and flakey. I have to use several coats to even get ok volume. I love a lot of mufe products but this mascara did not cut it, especially with the 22$ price tag nothing special (:

Rox O.
Pure love!

I just love this mascara, combined with They're Real they give me the perfect lashes! I never need to use false lashes anymore! :) The price is not so great and in a few weeks the mascara dries out. But worth it.

Lisa May L.

I love this mascara. I purchased this a couple of times and never has it once disappointed me. I love the application because I don't have to use a heavy hand to apply and it's barely ever clumpy. Def will purchase again!

Janel B.
Gives my lashes the extra boost.

My lashes are already long and thick to begin with, but when it comes to mascara I try to find mascaras that will define my lashes. I'm hesitant when it comes to mascaras that cost more than $20 so I was pretty happy when my friend purchased this mascara for my birthday. Not only does this mascara make my lashes look long and black but they flare out my lashes for more definition.

I'm not a big fan of the brush since it's still the old fashion bristles, which still tends to flake. Docking half a star for the price and another half for the bristles, but if the brushes turned plastic like Benefits and Buxom Lashes this mascara would be absolutely perfect.

Jill O.
all dried up

I got a mini one once in a sephora lash sampler set and it was the only one in the bath that was all dry and nasty. Almost unusable.

Then I got a gift set which had a full sized, I was excited because I wanted to give it another shot. It too was all dried up.

Not worth the fuss if they show up half the time all dried up.

Sofia M.
It's good but not great.

It makes your lashes dark and thicker and longer. but honestly? for $25 dollars it's not worth it. I achieve the same thing with Telescopic Carbon Black plus better lengthening for half the price. Oh and ps it flaked on me a lot too

Melissa W.
Finally, one that fits!

It has taken me forever (no pun intended) to find a mascara after suddenly becoming allergic to Lancome. I had to settle for cheap, drug store, sensitive skin brands that did very little to make my lashes pop like MUFE's Smoky Lash does. It's a keeper for me. Only bummer for me is that it flakes a bit, but I can live with that because it makes my eyes pop!

Ashlee L.
Makeup Artist Essential

This mascara is an essential piece to my makeup kit. I have both waterproof and original in black. It is the most perfect formula and doesn't flake. I recommend this to every bride that I work with and swear by it. I love it because it hold a curl all day and give you the longest most sexiest lashes even without a lash curler. I recommend this to my Asian babies too since this can keep a curl on even the most stubborn lashes. For stubborn lashes that don't like to curl I find that the waterproof formula has bulletproof staying power for fabulous lashes all day and night. Two thumbs up!

2 found this helpful.
Thalia M.
My go-to!

I find it hard to judge mascaras in store, since you really can't play around with the wand and get the full effect. So I had apprehensions when I brought this home.

I have to say, this is my favorite mascara now! I have pushed my Dior aside and am having an exclusive relationship with Smoky Eyes! It just makes my lashes full and long, and doesn't stays in place all day! I use a couple coats on both top and bottom lashes daily. I feel like this is a great mascara to use without eyeliner (a look I don't go for a lot), because it really sticks to them. I don't get that tarantula-lashes-look a lot of mascaras give when they say they make your lashes look "full".

I will say one "con" with this product is that it's tough to remove. you definitely don't want to be tugging at your delicate eyelids, so use an oil-based remover. I got a deluxe sample size of their "sens-eyes" remover with this, and that does the trick, too.

I see a lot of people are unhappy with the price on this, but there are definitely lots of mascaras out there with higher price points. In fact, at $22, it beats my Diorshow $24.50, and is in line with my Buxom amplified and my Stila major MAJOR lash.

Julie A.
Great but $$

I'm going to start by saying, I really wanted to hate this mascara given the $22 price tag. However, after my first use I realized how amazing it is. One of the key elements in this mascara is the wand, I am not a fan of plastic bendy hard fake brissles so the fact that has natural hairs is awesome and makes it so much easier to apply. The effect this gives my lashes is incredible, they look super black, long and thick. I did not notice any flaking, but as my tube got older the formulation seemed to clump a bit. I didn't really mind so much because the results were worth the extra effort. I've since finished my tube and have not yet repurchased for two reasons: 1) I no longer live near any Sephoras (so sad!) and 2) I really can't justify the price tag, given that there are so many other wonderful mascaras for half the price. A great alternative is Clinique's high impact mascara ($14.50) which has a similar wand and gives great natural looking lashes. Drug store options include Loreal Voluminous (beware of clumping!) and Maybelline Full n' Soft (one of my all time favs). If price isn't an issue for you though, then I highly suggest this!