e.l.f.

Waterproof Eyeliner Pen

Reviews

Holly M.
I love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I love it so much I tried to find a eyeliner that helps me put my eyeliner an correctly and it works. Its really good it gives good color payoff but it smudges a little if your eyes are watery (like mine) but its really good. YAY!!

Rachelle-Denise  M.
Sadly, A Miss...

I am always scoping out the drug store for my e.l.f products! I am a girl on a budget so makeup for $1 is my addiction! I am sad to say that this product was a miss. *tear* There's no way to control how much liner you get with applying and it's almost like the tip gets dry--like a marker. It makes applying a winged eye a forever endeavor! I've had better.

Celina T.

This liner SUCKS. I used this one time and it dried out. I thought it was just the pen so I went to a better store to get another and the same thing happened. The color payoff is good but it would be nice if it ever lasted. But I guess you get what you pay for. (Its only $1.00)

Tyni R.
Good but not waterproof

This would have been great if it really was waterproof. The pen is light. The tip, I like! It did not fray on me and I securely cap it so that it won't dry out. Upon application, this liquid eyeliner dries up easily. It's great for precision eye lining. It does kind of suck though that I get a slight smudge on my lids after a few hours even though my lids aren't that oily. This would definitely be a disaster for very oily lids! Plus, not good if you unexpectedly tear up or cry haha!

Added: I always cap it correctly but I think it either dried up on me or there's really not much product in it. I can't repurchase since that would be wasting money. :(

Lyna N.
Good for Beginners

It's a felt tip eyeliner, It's shaped like a marker so it's really great for control. It does dry up a bit quickly! It isn't the blackest eyeliner but for $2 it isn't bad.

Marilou D.

Actually, this is the first time I’ve used ELF cosmetics. This eyeliner pen has a felt-tip that allows a good amount of control and is easy to use. And since it is waterproof, it doesn't smudge. It dries for only 3 days! It’s because I had it stored tip up. I’ve read from a blog that you have to stored it upside down so it won’t dry. I’ve wanted to give it a try again, and this time, i’ll surely let it stored upside down. :)

http://princessmacarons.tumblr.com/post/5762867334

Angelica O.
Really Disappointed!

I bought this because I thought it was worth a try for only $1. The first day I used it I kind of liked it. Application was easy, the tip of the pen allowed for precise lines and I could control the thickness of the lines. However, after the first week the color wasn't as pigmented as it was the first day I used it. It came out like a washed down black color (kind of grey) and the pen was drying out. Well, for a dollar it's not really a huge disappointment, I guess. I should've expected it.

Shelbi V.
Makes life easier!

So when i bought this i was kinda scephtic..But when i tried it i fell in love. It makes doing cat eyes so easy! The lid can be kinda tricky somtimes cause it doesnt close all the way but for a dollar this is a wonderful product i will deffently be repurchasing :]

Brittany D.
You get what you pay for.

I only paid $1 for this eyeliner pen, but I suppose you could say it was a dollar well spent? After purchase, I was able to use this pen for about a month before it dried out. I tried putting a little water on the tip to help it stay moist, but it didn't work. But I mean for $1, you get what you pay for.

Stacie P.
Dried out!

I bought this with my first e.l.f haul back in July. I am quite disappointed in it! It arrived dried out and barely even showed up! The parts that did show up were an icky gray color; not very attractive at all!

The only reason I gave this 1 1/2 stars is because it is definitely waterproof. Took me forever to get the dang product off!