Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner


Jordana K.
Love love love love love

In the UK, unless we go internet, Stila is quite hard to find. So when I walked into Boots, imagine the fangirl dance I did when I saw a brand new Stila stand, so new that it didn't even have testers yet. I bought a beach palette and this eyeliner in Stingray (black)

Oh my flipping flip flip, what did I ever do without it? It sticks to your waterline and does not move. Theres no liner fallout beyond the lashline when applied on the waterline and it blends like a dream!!! Its amazing - go get it now lol! I know I'll be getting more colors when my funds replenish themselves!

5 found this helpful.
Angela s.

I'm in love with this liner, I have it in 3 colors. These liners are very pigmented and go on very nice. This is the first crayon liner I've found that doesn't smudge/run through the day, and stays on the water line for more then 6hrs, AMAZING. So if I put it on at 9am it will look the same way by 5pm it's great. Yes it is $20 but its well worth it, and no matter what anyone says I haven't found any drugstore crayon liner thats comparable to this one that has its staying power. Def a solid 5 star product that I recommend.

4 found this helpful.
Monique B.
Love this!

I really love this eyeliner, I have never been able to line my upper lids with a pencil eye liner. I can with this one, the color is very black and it is so simple to apply, it also glides on so smoothly. I can also wear this on my bottom waterline which is rare for me my eyes tend to not let anything stay on my waterline. This was given to me as a present but I will be buying another for sure.

4 found this helpful.
Laura O.

This liner is amazing!!! The color is super black, applies so smoothly and last forever in my eyes. Also, as a big plus, I love the fact that you don't have to be sharpening it. I've always like these type of pencils but the formula were too dry. But these ones, OMG I will love these forever!

2 found this helpful.
Emily B.
beware contact lens wearers!!
Photo of product included with review by Emily B.

This is an excellent waterproof liner for those of you out there gifted with perfect eyesight (or who prefer to wear glasses). It really is smudge proof, the color Damsel is a lovely dark brown, and it applies smoothly with minimal tugging.

However: for those who wear contacts, this eyeliner is sadly not a good option for you (unless you’re comfortable with hazy blurry vision in one or both eyes). I went through six pairs of contacts (in two days!) before realizing that the constantly appearing cloudy smudge on my contact lenses was the result of this eyeliner. It doesn’t come off with cleaning, soaking or rubbing the lens - the smudge is there to stay, just as it is on your eyelid. I do tightline my upper waterline so it’s possible that keeping the liner on your lid/upper lash line only will keep your contacts safe, but consider carefully before buying!! Attached is a photo of a lens that I wore today for a few hours.

2 found this helpful.
Brie S. Team
The Best!

If you love eyeliner and use it daily this is the best thing to happen to your eyes. There are so many colors to choose from. I love "Lionfish" it has gold flex in it and it brightens my brown eyes.

I love using this liner to tight-line my eyes. This liner dries quickly but within the first few minutes of application you are able to smudge it as the title states. I will take a angled brush to smudge out my liner or to create a smoky wing. This liner never runs or bleeds, and It stays put. Worth the buy!

1 found this helpful.
Chyna W.

This is officially my new go-to liner! I actually ended up getting this liner along with the new Stila palette I purchased today...So I figured I would use it. Unfortunately I had a death in the family so I was crying a lot today. Not only did this liner last all night...but I was amazed when I looked to see if my makeup was running and it still looked perfect. I'm definielty a fan of this eyeliner for sure now! ^_^

1 found this helpful.
Crimson K.
One of the BEST Waterpoof Pencils on the market!

The color Stingray (the most pure black that you can find) is a staple in my makeup kit as well as my personal collection. This is one of the only pencils I can use in my waterline that will stay all day without making me look like Tammy Faye Baker when I get home from work. It's worth every penny!

1 found this helpful.
Michelle L.
Pretty much amazing!

I have this eyeliner in Stingray and I absolutely LOVE it!! I can't live without black eyeliner. I feel incomplete without it. I have used many different brands in the past and sometimes I'll stick to brands longer than others until the next best thing comes along. Well voila! I have found it! I have really sensitive eyes and when my allergies act up they get really watery and itchy. When this happens its hard to keep my makeup intact, especially my eyeliner. This liner did not was perfect the whole day!! I only have one little teeny tiny problem with it... it doesn't last me as long as the other liners I've tried. Other than that it's pretty much amazing!

1 found this helpful.
Emma M.
Ah great product!

I purchased two of these when Ulta had it's sale during the 21 Days of Beauty when they were buy one get one free! So at $20 each, I decided it would be a good deal to try them out now. They are so easy to smudge and are highly pigmented. I got the shades Peacock and Purple Tang. Peacock is a vibrant teal shade and Purple Tang is a dark purple, almost black with dark purple glitter throughout. It took forever to get the swatches off my hand lol. These last forever!!

1 found this helpful.